Reviews
From the Land of the Moon
Original titleMal de pierres
Directed by Nicole Garcia · starring Marion Cotillard, Louis Garrel and Àlex Brendemühl
- 7 from the press
- 7.0 · 4 votes
From the Land of the Moon: reviews
Reviews
7.0 4 votes
What the critics say average 5.5 from 6 outlets
- 7.0 The Hollywood ReporterDorah Young
Cotillard's performance is luminous throughout, enriching the willful heroine with the depth of a single obsession.
Read - 7.0 Screen DailyAllan Hunter
The ingredients of an old-fashioned romantic weepie are given class and conviction by director Nicole Garcia whose elegant restraint helps to ground the more fanciful elements in some sense of reality.
Read - 7.0 The WrapSteve Pond
This is Cotillard?s film, and she's tremendously affecting in what was no doubt a tricky role to pull off.
Read - 4.0 VarietyJessica Kiang
[It] is as syrupy a confection as ever dripped from the pen of Nicholas Sparks [...] Instead we get this borderline pastiche of the French romantic melodrama.
Read - 4.0 The GuardianHenry Barnes
The film takes on Gabrielle's listlessness, slumps into an opiated fug. The malady is mysterious and not easily treatable. It just exhausts you. It transforms from a story about release to just another jail. At times it felt like there was no escape.
Read - 4.0 El PaísCarlos Boyero
It has an aroma of old movies in the worst sense, it is visually academic. (...) The best is the interpretation of that excellent actress named Marion Cotillard. But it's not enough.
Read - El MundoLuis Martinez
The little justification of her character, [...] next to the almost ridiculous structure of the final in the form of a paranoid thriller, ends up ruining a project that demanded a much more altered, passionate and frantic pulse.
Read
Questions about the reviews of From the Land of the Moon
- What score does From the Land of the Moon have?
- Readers give it 7.0 (4 votes). The critics, 5.5 on average from 6 reviews.
- What do the critics say about From the Land of the Moon?
- The highest score is The Hollywood Reporter’s (7.0) and the lowest El País’s (4.0).