Reviews
Midway
Directed by Roland Emmerich · starring Peter Shinkoda, Jake Manley and Nico DeCastris
- 10 from the press
- 5.9 · 9 votes
Midway: reviews
Reviews
5.9 9 votes
- 100 %
- 90 %
- 833 %
- 722 %
- 611 %
- ≤533 %
What the critics say average 4.1 from 10 outlets
- 5.5 Time OutJoshua Rothkopf
Emmerich?s eye for historical detail is scary (...) The movie becomes a superior entertainment, briefly, whenever it shifts focus to the military strategists behind the hardware.
Read - 5.5 The TelegraphTim Robey
A mixed bag (...) 'Midway' will never be mistaken for a classic (...) Stretches of the film work beautifully, though.
Read - 5.0 Screen DailyTim Grierson
The film lacks the excitement of the director?s best [work] (...) 'Midway' may educate some viewers about a crucial battle, but by straining to be respectful, it fails to be particularly stirring.
Read - 4.0 VarietyOwen Gleiberman
Roland Emmerich stages the Battle of Midway as a convincing historical combat spectacle, though his storytelling remains B-movie basic
Read - 4.0 The GuardianCath Clarke
A long, loud and tedious history lesson (...) The best thing to do with this movie would be to take cover and wait for it to pass.
Read - 4.0 IndiewireDavid Ehrlich
The way Emmerich tells [the story] feels more informed by WWII movies than it does by the war itself (...) [It] lacks any conviction of its own.
Read - 3.5 The A.V. ClubIgnatiy Vishnevetsky
Emmerich is almost completely eluded by the larger sweep of history and war (...) which makes the many subplots of Wes Tooke?s screenplay seem extraneous or pointless.
Read - 3.0 The Hollywood ReporterJohn DeFore
Unfortunately, even a moviegoer who (like this one) is theoretically willing to see yesteryear's war-film genre reanimated with 21st-century production values will find little to love in 'Midway'.
Read - 3.0 The Washington PostMichael O'Sullivan
A big, old-fashioned war movie, with one thing missing: human beings.
Read - 3.0 EmpireIan Freer
This is a war movie where no-one shows fear, doubt, confusion or anguish (...) In a post 'Saving Private Ryan'-'Dunkirk' landscape, it feels astonishing anyone is still making war movies like this.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Midway
- What score does Midway have?
- Readers give it 5.9 (9 votes). The critics, 4.1 on average from 10 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Midway?
- The highest score is Time Out’s (5.5) and the lowest Empire’s (3.0).