Advertising Remove ads
Yellow Rose poster

Reviews

Yellow Rose

starring Eva Noblezada, Libby Villari and Lea Salonga

  • 15 from the press

Yellow Rose: reviews

Reviews

What the critics say average 7.0 from 15 outlets

  • 8.9 The Austin ChronicleBeth Sullivan If left in less deft hands, the film could’ve teetered into a too-on-the-nose commentary on America’s current immigration debate. However, the lean screenplay and Paragas’ focused creative vision makes for a singular directorial feature debut that feels like nothing else happening in film right now. Read
  • 8.8 The Globe and MailSarah Hagi Ultimately, the film isn’t about a happy ending or even a real conclusion – as in real life, we’re not sure what will happen to Rose or where she will end up. But what we are left with is a true and honest account of how quickly the lives of millions change overnight. Read
  • 8.0 ABC NewsPeter Travers Eva Noblezada is just the breakout actress and singer to punch through the familiar contours of “Yellow Rose” to find its beating heart. Read
  • 7.5 Chicago TribuneKatie Walsh Yellow Rose is an emotional blunt instrument. It’s not exactly subtle, but then again, the best country songs, and the best coming-of-age tales, rarely are. Read
  • 7.5 Movie NationRoger Moore Casting Salonga, a singing actress best known for Disney’s animated “Mulan,” and not letting her sing is a cheat. But Watson is a laid-back delight and makes Rose’s odyssey make sense musically and emotionally. Read
  • 7.5 San Francisco ChronicleCary Darling But that’s also the movie’s charm, painting a world where all you need is talent, a little luck and a couple of shoulders to cry on when things get tough. It’s a stripped-down “A Star Is Born” — without the rehab and suicide. Read
  • 7.5 IndiewireKate Erbland Paragas’ film finds fresh ground to explore the price and the power of the American dream, bolstered by country crooning and heartbreaking (and very real) legal worries. It’s a concept that might sound played out, but deft directing and a number of strong performances recommend it, a down-home answer to the similarly charming 2018 drama “Wild Rose.” Read
  • 7.0 VarietyPeter Debruge Like Andrew Ahn’s “Driveways” earlier this year, “Yellow Rose” is ultimately a film about kindness. The world can be cruel, but the film’s characters tend not to be. Group those movies with Sundance prize winner “Minari,” and audiences have three terrific indies about growing up Asian in America — although this is the only one that sets the experience to music. Read
  • 6.3 Associated PressJake Coyle “Yellow Rose” sings an affecting, sorrowful and defiant song where dreams collide with a cruel reality. Read
  • 6.3 Roger EbertCarlos Aguilar In the end, the neatly wrapped resolution amounts to a sense of incompleteness, like a concert that leaves you waiting for an encore. Read
  • 6.0 New York TimesKristen Yoonsoo Kim Above all, the music has the greatest staying power — it is the film’s saving grace, just like it is Rose’s during her darkest days. Read
  • 6.0 The GuardianLeslie Felperin Noblezada has great pipes and a natural screen presence that augurs well for her future career. Read
  • 6.0 Página/12Diego Brodersen But if predictability is one of its birthmarks, so is the freshness of near-debutant Eva Noblezada, who, far from pouting and dramatic overload, builds a complex creature, at once fragile and resilient. Read
  • 5.8 The A.V. ClubLawrence Garcia Yellow Rose may not be a success on the whole, but it does suggest that Paragas, like her protagonist, is still finding her way. Read
  • 5.5 The WrapAlonso Duralde Even with such an underwritten character, Noblezada finds grace notes and moments of specificity to Rose; it’s got to be a challenge for a stage star to portray a performer with nervousness about crowds, but she conveys the character’s stage fright (and the degrees to which she eventually overcomes it) in a way that feels honest. Read
Advertising Remove ads

Questions about the reviews of Yellow Rose

What score does Yellow Rose have?
The critics, 7.0 on average from 15 reviews.
What do the critics say about Yellow Rose?
The highest score is The Austin Chronicle’s (8.9) and the lowest The Wrap’s (5.5).
Advertising Remove ads