Advertising Remove ads
12 Mighty Orphans poster

Reviews

12 Mighty Orphans

starring Luke Wilson, Vinessa Shaw and Wayne Knight

  • 16 from the press

12 Mighty Orphans: reviews

Reviews

What the critics say average 5.0 from 16 outlets

  • 7.0 VarietyPeter Debruge It’s all engineered to pay off in familiar ways, though the movie isn’t quite as predictable as you might think. Read
  • 7.0 CinemagaviaJavi Sardi Doce Huérfanos is another film about overcoming the odds and American football, drawing on many of the genre’s clichés. The pairing of Luke Wilson and Martin Sheen works quite well, and each scene seems to fit with the next, so it never gets too heavy. Read
  • 6.7 The Film StageJared Mobarak The delineation between good and evil maybe a bit too black-and-white throughout, but none of those aspects remove the potency of the lessons learned along the way. Read
  • 6.7 The Globe and MailBrad Wheeler With its old-fashioned look, quaint unsophistication and self-consciously big heart, this film is Hoosiers meets The Longest Yard, with an Oliver Twist. Read
  • 6.0 Los Angeles TimesNoel Murray Again, credit Wilson and Sheen — with the latter playing a kindly old drunken doctor who lays off his flask for a while to help the kids drive to a championship. Nothing that happens in “12 Mighty Orphans” is unexpected, but these two pros still react with infectious wonder as the messages they send to their students take root and then sprout. Read
  • 6.0 El DebateJuan Orellana In short, a family film (leaving out the youngest children), positive, comforting and with undeniable values. But also extremely Yankee. Read
  • 5.0 San Francisco ChronicleCary Darling The results may be sports-movie predictable in many ways, but the Mighty Mites’ impossible story is one deserving of resurrection from the dusty archives of Texas history. Read
  • 5.0 Roger EbertCarlos Aguilar Wholesome in the most “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” brand of mythical Americanism, “12 Mighty Orphans” is engineered to rouse emotions with uncritical pride, never reaching the less immaculate corners of the historical period it employs as canvas. Read
  • 5.0 The PlaylistAndrew Crump Ultimately it’s very little about football. It’s about class. This is a theme worthy of a spotlight, too — but “12 Mighty Orphans” isn’t the place for it, or it shouldn’t be. Read
  • 5.0 The Washington PostMichael O'Sullivan If you’re looking for that kind of moral-rich message, delivered with equal amounts of sincerity and syrup, congratulations: You may have found the mythical source from which all other malarkey springs.
  • 5.0 The A.V. ClubMike D'Angelo 12 Mighty Orphans tells the true story of a Depression-era high school football team improbably formed at a Texas orphanage, but the screenplay may as well have been invented from whole cloth, given its relentlessly formulaic nature. Read
  • 4.0 Screen DailyTim Grierson Luke Wilson and Martin Sheen are respectably earnest as the caretakers of these blandly noble underdogs, but this sepia-tinged portrait slavishly follows the playbook at every turn — which is ironic since it’s a film meant to honour a coach who won by being inventive. Read
  • 3.8 Movie NationRoger Moore As a director, Roberts comes off as more of a producer. He can get a movie made, he’s just damned artless in making it. Read
  • 3.0 New York TimesBen Kenigsberg 12 Mighty Orphans is a plodding football drama in which the characters talk to one another like folksy social workers. Read
  • 2.5 Original-CinLiam Lacey Sometimes researching the background of a movie proves more revealing than the film itself. Read
  • 2.0 The Austin ChronicleJenny Nulf There is no denying that being parentless during the Great Depression called for a lot of resilience, but 12 Mighty Orphans’ underdog story unfortunately plays out to farce levels of entertainment. Read
Advertising Remove ads

Questions about the reviews of 12 Mighty Orphans

What score does 12 Mighty Orphans have?
The critics, 5.0 on average from 16 reviews.
What do the critics say about 12 Mighty Orphans?
The highest score is Variety’s (7.0) and the lowest The Austin Chronicle’s (2.0).
Advertising Remove ads