Big Stone Gap: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 4.4 from 11 outlets
- 6.3 Roger EbertGlenn Kenny
The movie ambles along amiably enough for a while; it’s better if you are a fan of one or more members of the cast.
Read - 5.0 New York PostKyle Smith
Long on heart if short on surprises, “Big Stone Gap” is an easygoing visit to small-town America.
Read - 5.0 Tampa Bay TimesSteve Persall
Big Stone Gap isn't everyone's cup of sweet tea. It's a homespun tale populated by broadly drawn characters and solid actors — Whoopi Goldberg, Jane Krakowski, Anthony LaPaglia — sounding like they gulped hush puppy batter.
Read - 5.0 The Washington PostJen Chaney
Big Stone Gap suffers from some hokey moments, including an ending that’s both implausible and too heavy on the sap.
- 5.0 The Philadelphia InquirerMolly Eichel
The plot itself has little momentum, and what should feel dramatic instead feels inert.
Read - 5.0 The Hollywood ReporterFrank Scheck
Featuring a stellar cast apparently seeking to prove that they’re interested in being popular in red states as well as blue, Big Stone Gap goes down relatively easy, but it contains lots of empty calories.
Read - 4.2 The A.V. ClubA.A. Dowd
The result is at once labor of love and cautionary tale: Apparently too close to the story to recognize how ill suited she was to translating its charms to the screen, Trigiani has emerged with nothing but corny, stilted Americana, like something Garrison Keillor might burp out on a really off day.
- 4.0 The Austin ChronicleKimberley Jones
But the film is as thin as a picture postcard.
Read - 3.0 The Arizona RepublicRandy Cordova
Nothing feels believable in “Big Stone Gap,” a bungled, charm-free look at small-town life in the South in the late '70s.
Read - 3.0 Los Angeles TimesGary Goldstein
The movie mostly plays so strained and corn pone that it undermines its sincere emotional core and good intentions.
Read - 2.5 Chicago Sun-TimesRichard Roeper
The intended charms of the down-home period piece/Southern comedy/romance/drama Big Stone Gap were utterly lost on me.
Questions about the reviews of Big Stone Gap
- What score does Big Stone Gap have?
- The critics, 4.4 on average from 11 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Big Stone Gap?
- The highest score is Roger Ebert’s (6.3) and the lowest Chicago Sun-Times’s (2.5).