Reviews
Disappearance at Clifton Hill
starring Maxwell McCabe-Lokos, Elizabeth Saunders and Tuppence Middleton
- 10 from the press
Disappearance at Clifton Hill: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.0 from 10 outlets
- 7.5 Original-CinLinda Barnard
Middleton plays Abby with a pleasing note of vulnerability that is often supplanted by a nagging anticipation she’ll tip off the edge. She and Gross have smooth chemistry as estranged sisters.
Read - 7.0 Los Angeles TimesNoel Murray
where “Disappearance at Clifton Hill” really excels is in exploring the visual and sonic textures of a decaying resort, and in hailing the plucky resourcefulness of a broken woman, trying to piece her memories — and maybe herself — back together.
Read - 6.7 The Film StageChristopher Schobert
This is a standard unsolved mystery drama, the type that would be quite at home on a small-screen police procedural. The setting certainly adds to its interest, but even when the boy’s fate is (seemingly) explained, it is difficult to care.
Read - 6.3 Slant MagazineChuck Bowen
What distinguishes the film from much of its ilk is Albert Shin’s ongoing taste for peculiar and unsettling details.
Read - 6.0 The Hollywood ReporterSheri Linden
But for all its vividly detailed eccentricity, the movie, like Abby, connects the dots rather too easily. As Clifton Hill digs deeper into exceedingly sordid stuff, it doesn’t dish up the kind of aha moments or chilling frissons that would lift the story from clever contrivance — until a final, delicious twist pulls the rug out from under this richly atmospheric but not always convincing tale.
Read - 6.0 New York TimesGlenn Kenny
For patient or forgiving fans of idiosyncratic thrillers, “Disappearance” may deliver satisfactory spills and chills.
Read - 5.0 The PlaylistAndrew Bundy
For all its strange and specific flavor, “Clifton Hill” is too tame and tepid to truly work as weird noir.
Read - 5.0 VarietyScott Tobias
Shin’s Niagara Falls has human casualties that are shattered into pieces in the gorge, but there are quieter, more personal tragedies that cut against a destination that’s designed, at times mercilessly, to make people happy. His film leaves a vivid impression without quite leaving a mark.
Read - 5.0 Movie NationRoger Moore
a muddled mystery-thriller that’s something of a wash, one that director-turned-actor David Cronenberg all but steals.
Read - 5.0 Roger EbertNick Allen
never as fun as it should be, despite a gripping central crime
Read
Questions about the reviews of Disappearance at Clifton Hill
- What score does Disappearance at Clifton Hill have?
- The critics, 6.0 on average from 10 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Disappearance at Clifton Hill?
- The highest score is Original-Cin’s (7.5) and the lowest Roger Ebert’s (5.0).