Good One: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 8.3 from 36 outlets
- 10 Associated PressLindsey Bahr
All of the acting is terrific and so naturalistic that it’s easy to forget that these are actors performing lines that they’ve memorized in front of a camera.
Read - 10 Roger EbertSheila O'Malley
“Good One” is intriguing in its disinterest in explanations. The film’s refusal to “satisfy” an audience with easy explanations or even cathartic moments pulls you into its atmosphere, dragging you into the weird dynamic which grows more claustrophobic by the moment.
Read - 10 Los Angeles TimesRobert Abele
In its lived-in quality and gathering churn, “Good One” is a dream of an indie, from the craft in every frame to the humor, epiphanies and mysteries that gird its portraiture.
Read - 10 Rolling StoneDavid Fear
Good One is, among its infinite attributes, an ode to a style of filmmaking that appears to be humble, yet still manages to be devastating and humanistic to its very core. Mostly, it’s just a great fucking movie, full stop.
Read - 9.3 The AtlanticShirley Li
Good One, a deceptively simple Sundance gem just released in theaters, depicts all of that emotional chaos in just three days, in the middle of the woods.
Read - 9.1 ConsequenceClint Worthington
From the get, Donaldson has a tremendous command of pace and silence, laying the desperation of middle age (and how it looks to those whose lives are still ahead of them) bare with little more than a gesture or a closeup. It’s a killer debut for both her and Collias, and it will be exciting to see what both can do with the momentum a picture like this can provide.
Read - 9.1 Original-CinChris Knight
Good One, a lesson in minimalist storytelling from first-time feature writer-director India Donaldson, is a movie that sneaks up on you.
Read - 9.0 ColliderChase Hutchinson
Through it all, Collias is so confident and assured that it feels like this is her fiftieth leading role instead of her first.
Read - 9.0 Film ThreatBobby LePire
Good One is a carefully crafted character study. It’s brought to life by perfectly calibrated performances, led by the young but brilliant Lily Collias. This is one hike everyone should experience.
Read - 9.0 New York TimesAlissa Wilkinson
Good One is the writer and director India Donaldson’s feature debut, and an astounding one, full of the kind of emotional detail that can only come from personal experience.
Read - 9.0 SlateSam Adams
Good One is a quiet movie, not because it has little to say but because it wants you to listen, to pay as much attention to what’s left unsaid as to its meticulously crafted dialogue, and to the way silence can be a power as well as a punishment.
Read - 8.9 The Austin ChronicleKimberley Jones
Out of a tight, terrific cast, it’s Collias’ performance – so alert and contained, its potency comes on later, like a time-release pill – that gets under your skin. It’s a star-making turn: not just a good one, a great one.
Read - 8.8 LarsenOnFilmJosh Larsen
Good One is a crafty feature debut from writer-director India Donaldson, in that its unassuming air and “small” story create little ripples that eventually coalesce into something shattering.
Read - 8.8 The Daily BeastNick Schager
A contemplative indie about a hiking trip that’s marked by middle-age malaise, teen unease, and uncomfortable intergenerational dynamics, this Sundance Film Festival standout, in theaters, on Aug. 9, proves a quietly explosive tale of disconnection and betrayal, its placid exterior masking a wellspring of combustible tensions that are both impossible to ignore and difficult to resolve.
Read - 8.8 The Washington PostTy Burr
Good One takes advantage of the summer lushness of the Catskills, Wilson Cameron’s nature-centric cinematography and Celia Hollander’s ruminative acoustic score to cast a spell over its 89 sure-footed minutes.
Read - 8.3 The Film StageJordan Raup
Good One is an acutely felt portrait of impending womanhood and a remarkable debut for India Donaldson.
Read - 8.3 IndiewireDavid Ehrlich
Modest and casual until the exact moment when the film’s master plan suddenly clicks into place like the hammer of a gun transforming a neutral tool into a deadly weapon, “Good One” is the kind of movie that tightens its complete lack of tension into a knot in the pit of your stomach.
Read - 8.3 The PlaylistRodrigo Perez
It’s a sublime little travelogue, deceptively simple, engaging, and thoughtful, and perhaps not unlike some of the keen filmmaking made by Kelly Reichardt, of which the film bears some encouraging similarities.
Read - 8.3 The A.V. ClubKatie Rife
Good One is beautifully observed, making its point without being too obvious, and perfectly judged in that it doesn’t waste a single shot. The beats of the film are simple and straightforward, but if you hone in on the details, every second is full of information.
Read - 8.0 The Hollywood ReporterDavid Rooney
All three principal performances are expertly synced and feel entirely lived in. But it’s Collias who gives the minimalist character study its lingering emotional amplitude, conveying the volatile inner life of a woman making discoveries not only about her camping companions but also about herself.
Read - 8.0 VarietyGuy Lodge
Collias impresses in a role that doesn’t grant her any great extremes of expression. Sam’s temperate demeanor may simply be her nature, but Collias’s tautly wired performance shows how it’s also a defense.
Read - 8.0 Screen DailyAllan Hunter
The ending is as low-key as the rest of the film, but the subtle shifts in power and understanding feel like a significant coming of age.
Read - 8.0 TimeStephanie Zacharek
Collias captures something gossamer here, a quiet shift into adult womanhood that happens, literally, overnight.
Read - 8.0 The GuardianPeter Bradshaw
It is very intelligent and humane, and what a great performance from Collias.
Read - 8.0 The Irish TimesTara Brady
India Donaldson’s Good One is a sneaky revelation, a low-key coming-of-age drama that deftly sidesteps familiar tropes in favour of keen cringe comedy and emotional precision.
Read - 8.0 The TimesKevin Maher
Towards the end, that mood changes devastatingly. Another film might have needed a murder to send these chills but Donaldson is in such control of the tone, and her cast are on such exquisite form, that a single sentence has massive reverberations.
Read - 8.0 Otros CinesDiego Batlle
India Donaldson works with an assurance and ease, a power of observation, a flexibility and a wealth of nuance and subtlety that are rare in contemporary cinema, and rarer still in a first-time director.
Read - 8.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer
GOOD ONE brings into play, in small doses, the same tensions that other films take hours to describe and analyze.
Read - 8.0 EspinofPedro Gallego
The film’s ninety minutes follow an unwavering straight line, but they end up finding emotional treasures in pregnant silent pauses and glances that reveal more than they should.
Read - 7.5 Slant MagazineGregory Nussen
The film instinctively and lucidly shows how sometimes a coming of age can be thrust upon a person against their will.
Read - 7.5 CinemagaviaSoraya Unión Álvarez
Writer-director India Donaldson weaves a moving, understated and meditative portrait of the relationship between a father and a daughter.
Read - 7.1 Paste MagazineJesse Hassenger
Still, this is a striking introduction to Donaldson’s unflinching eye.
Read - 7.0 El antepenúltimo mohicanoRubén Téllez Brotons
Donaldson sets out to write a cinematic haiku on the screen, one in which contemplating the landscape where the action unfolds at times matters more than the small conflicts that arise between the characters.
Read - 6.0 Screen RantMae Abdulbaki
The film is compelling and quietly thought-provoking as it peels back the layers of the relationships at the forefront, while also showcasing the discomfort that follows but isn’t always picked up on.
Read - 6.0 The Wall Street JournalZachary Barnes
It feels mostly believable but a bit too obvious, as the meaning of the movie seems to shrink in its final minutes to fit a theme. Still, as a debut, “Good One” is good enough, a sensitively performed drama of a journey into the wild.
Read - 6.0 Decine21José María Aresté
This is a slow-cooked film in which hardly anything happens, in beautifully photographed surroundings, and where saying anything more about the plot would rob the viewing experience of much of its charm.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Good One
- What score does Good One have?
- The critics, 8.3 on average from 36 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Good One?
- The highest score is Associated Press’s (10) and the lowest Decine21’s (6.0).