Reviews
Harbin
Original title하얼빈
starring Park Jeong-min, Jo Woo-jin and Lily Franky
- 25 from the press
Harbin: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.8 from 25 outlets
- 8.8 Shade StudiosAlfred Castaneda
Every scene in Harbin is beautifully shot and every decision the characters make carry moral consequences that you can feel off screen. It's a stunning work and a can't miss watch for historical drama fans, or fans of its well-casted and all star cast.
Read - 8.3 Sonic CinemaBrian Skutle
It can be complicated and dense, but it has clear momentum that I got into, seeing the machenizations of the plot come together, and the twists and turns along the way.
Read - 8.0 Women Write About ComicsLouis Skye
A visual feast for the eyes, Harbin highlights how necessary compassion is for humanity, but especially during times of war. If you're looking for a gripping watch that will have you at the edge of your seat, Harbin should be your first pick.
Read - 8.0 Loud and Clear ReviewsEmma Vine
Harbin is an important watch that is very much worth the time investment.
Read - 8.0 Houston ChronicleCary Darling
Along with cinematographer Hong Kyung-pyo ("Parasite," "Snowpiercer," "Burning"), he uses the screen as a canvas for some absolutely ravishing images. Shot in Latvia and China with a reported budget of $20 million, "Harbin" looks as if it cost much more.
Read - 7.5 Sarah G Vincent ViewsSarah Vincent
It is not a "rah, rah Korea is great" movie. It is not only about a decisive blow against Japan.
Read - 7.5 Dennis Schwartz Movie ReviewsDennis Schwartz
A stylish and tense period action thriller. It's strongly directed by the South Korean filmmaker Woo Min-ho ("The Man Standing Next"/"The Drug King") and smartly co-written by him and Min-Seong Kim.
Read - 7.5 La VanguardiaLeonor Mayor Ortega
From that point on, Woo Min-ho delivers a masterclass in genuine spy cinema. 'Harbin' lacks nothing. There's intrigue, traitors, lifelong rivals, torture, threats, surprise skirmishes, all of it set off by impeccable visuals and a first-rate score.
Read - 7.3 Battle Royale With CheeseDaniel Rester
Harbin tells a straightforward but riveting historical story and features explosive action sequences. Woo never quite settles on a tone, but he stages individual scenes with gusto. Hong's cinematography helps bring a richness to the film too.
Read - 7.0 HanCinemaWilliam Schwartz
Jung-geun and his compatriots struggle to believe in something, to do something, simply because the alternative is complete despair. And that's no way to live at all.
Read - 7.0 Culture MixCarla Hay
"Harbin" gives a suspenseful depiction of the 1909 plot by Korean fighters to assassinate Japanese prime minister Itō Hirobumi during Japan's takeover of Korea. The movie drags in the middle, but is overall a well-made historical drama.
Read - 7.0 The Lamplight ReviewBrent Hankins
With a healthy combination of action, atmosphere, and heart — not to mention a thrilling climax that might feel a bit heavy-handed were it not based on historical record — Harbin succeeds as a gripping thriller that sheds light on a pivotal moment in Korea's history.
Read - 7.0 The GateAndrew Parker
Impressive in scope and scale, this tale of revenge and an assassination attempt set amid the backdrop of the Korean fight for independence circa 1909 scratches a particular kind of old school itch.
Read - 7.0 VarietySiddhant Adlakha
The ploy involves numerous trains and several moving parts, resulting in a gripping last act that makes for a wonderful historical imagining. En route to this engaging climax, Woo also introduces a mystery element that keeps the wheels of the story turning, even when it may not have enough steam.
Read - 7.0 Screen DailyRobert Daniels
What Harbin lacks in memorable characters, it more than makes up for in its staging and craft. The action is beautifully composed, with set pieces that jump from woodland to desert and urban settings.
Read - 7.0 Boston HassleJoshua Polanski
Woo, in this, unexpectedly reminds me of the writer Michael Chabon: if the latter is capable of writing a bad book but not a bad sentence, the former is incapable of making a poor image.
Read - 6.3 Mark Reviews MoviesMark Dujsik
The movie has the simplicity of a neatly constructed and occasionally clever thriller, but within the bigger picture of the politics surrounding these characters and their actions, one can't help but feel the filmmakers have shortchanged the history, the figures, and the ideas of this tale.
Read - 6.2 MagaZinemaMarta Pedraza
What we get is a flat Hyun Bin, with no room to let his character's inner struggle show through. The cinematography, beautiful as it is, overshadows the characters instead of supporting them or giving them context.
Read - 6.0 The Japan TimesMark Schilling
All of the movies about Ahn have understandably been Korean, though the latest, Woo Min-ho's "Harbin" is not a flag-waving celebration of his violent gesture of resistance.
Read - 6.0 48 HillsDennis Harvey
Dense with background details and explication that may be somewhat daunting to non-Korean audiences, Harbin nonetheless maintains interest with a somber, tense mood spiked by occasional outbursts of violence.
Read - 6.0 Richard CrouseRichard Crouse
"Harbin" is a big, impressive film that essays life-and-death topics of colonialism and the price of freedom. It works best when it is in motion, on the battlefield, but should also offer something to students of history.
Read - 6.0 Midwest Film JournalNick Rogers
The real star here is cinematographer Hong Kyung-pyo, a longtime Bong Joon-ho collaborator who knows both from railway suspense (Snowpiercer) and intimate character drama (Broker).
Read - 6.0 The People's MoviesRobert Ewing
Instead, it is a very well-made and well-acted film that lacks tension. What frustrates me the most is the potential for greatness that it squanders.
Read - 5.0 Asynchronous MediaChristopher Cross
A well-acted period piece that never entirely stands out from the many other depictions of Japanese-occupied Korea, Harbin is just exciting enough to be engaging but rarely digs deep enough below the surface to feel like more than just an abbreviated recap of a moment in Korea's past.
Read - 2.5 Roger EbertSimon Abrams
It’s hard to imagine who might enjoy this deliberately slow and often punishingly slack historical drama.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Harbin
- What score does Harbin have?
- The critics, 6.8 on average from 25 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Harbin?
- The highest score is Shade Studios’s (8.8) and the lowest Roger Ebert’s (2.5).