Reviews
Pavements
Directed by Alex Ross Perry · starring Joe Keery, Jason Schwartzman and Noah Baumbach
- 24 from the press
Pavements: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 7.8 from 24 outlets
- 10 Roger EbertRobert Daniels
The only request you can make of a documentary is for it to be as interesting as its subject. Alex Ross Perry’s slippery experimental mockumentary “Pavements,” a film about the 1990s slacker band behind Slanted and Enchanted and Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain, is as gleefully idiosyncratic and as suspicious of mainstream success as the band and its fans.
Read - 10 Little White LiesLuke Hicks
The constant blurring of the lines makes for a fascinating, often hilarious, watch.
Read - 9.1 The Film StageDavid Katz
Perry’s film, one of his most accomplished and complete-feeling to date, exists in both a past and conditional tense. It gives a brilliant précis of one of indie music’s most influential artists: in its most conventional passages, it’s a visual and critical biography identifying the key features of their suburban and middle-American backgrounds, their initiation into “alt” culture and the art life as students, and their sometimes loving, often tentative rapport with the 90s’ big-money music industry.
Read - 9.0 Screen DailyJonathan Romney
At once a documentary about the band and its recent live reunion, and a fictional embroidery around its status (and missed opportunities), Pavements is a joyous, slyly subversive celebration that, while unlikely to persuade newcomers to the music, nevertheless catches the band’s wayward spirit, as well as the downright ordinariness that came as an alternative to the bloated rock band ethos.
Read - 8.3 IndiewireAdam Solomons
“Pavements” is an important documentary. It’s a reminder that the fourth (and fifth and sixth) wall can be smashed, that the rock doc can be reinvented. And that when the message is meta for meta’s sake, why not make the medium that way, too?
Read - 8.3 The PlaylistMarshall Shaffer
“Pavements” proves and embodies the brilliance of an iconic band. It’s a true testament to their enduring power that their creative genius serves as an inspiration not just to imitate but also to iterate.
Read - 8.3 ConsequenceJonah Krueger
Pavements is a genuinely unique watch that turns the idea of a rockumentary upside down. It at once delivers upon fans’ thirst to learn more about the band while respecting the fact that their inconsistent story is part of the appeal.
Read - 8.0 VarietyStephen Saito
It’s impossible not to be won over by the director’s efforts, which come to include at least four separate modes of production.
Read - 8.0 NMEMatthew Turner
Blending fact and fiction in intriguing and unexpected ways, the film is consistently entertaining and can be enjoyed whether you’re a longtime fan of the band or a total newcomer.
Read - 8.0 New York TimesAlissa Wilkinson
The low-key and never very mainstream Pavement seems like the last band that would get this treatment, and that’s the joke. But it also makes the band the perfect subject for what “Pavements” is slyly doing, and quite brilliantly, too.
Read - 8.0 ColliderRoss Bonaime
Perry’s work in Pavements is one of the wildest and unhinged approaches to a music documentary ever made, but the fact that he pulls it all together into something that isn’t a mess is a testament to Perry’s craft.
Read - 8.0 The Wall Street JournalZachary Barnes
His film, “Pavements,” is a Möbius strip of a music documentary, at once ardent in its affections and devilishly ironic in how it treats the norms of paying tribute.
Read - 8.0 Los Angeles TimesScott Tobias
And yet, let us whisper this part as quietly as possible: Perry sincerely believes in Pavement’s era-defining greatness. And with “Pavements,” he’s made a film that nobly and triumphantly searches for a way to capture the band’s essence.
Read - 8.0 The Irish TimesTara Brady
Perry and his editor, Robert Greene (using split screens and collage techniques), build a dizzying kaleidoscope of timelines, earnestness and glee. What emerges is a film that’s as formally adventurous and oddly affecting as the soundtrack.
Read - 8.0 EspinofPedro Gallego
Pavements is lifted by its unconventional perspective and ends up being one of the most remarkable music films of recent years.
Read - 8.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer
Pavements is a biopic in tune with the band's style and attitude, presenting itself as ironic, casual and even self-parodying, but deep down taking itself more seriously than it seems.
Read - 7.5 The A.V. ClubJesse Hassenger
It all threatens to resemble a hat on a hat, possibly worn by a snake eating its own tail. Yet Perry isn’t really going for a trippy hall-of-mirrors approach, even when he cuts together multiple performances of songs so that Pavements past, present, and fake-ass trade verses on their catalog of ’90s non-hits.
Read - 7.5 The Washington PostAnn Hornaday
Once Perry brings his magnum opus to its many climactic conclusions, the bait-and-switchy gamesmanship and sheer swing of his conceit have become irresistibly contagious, and viewers can’t help but be moved.
Read - 7.0 The Hollywood ReporterJordan Mintzer
His approach is one of a consummate enthusiast and completist, and he does manage to convey that dedicated fan energy on screen. But he doesn’t necessarily make it feel contagious enough.
Read - 7.0 Otros CinesDiego Batlle
Overly fragmented by its frantic editing (not a single Pavement song is ever heard in full, for instance), it is nonetheless a film tailored to the disruptive, unclassifiable spirit of the band (and of the hugely influential Matador Records label).
Read - 6.7 The Austin ChronicleKimberley Jones
Just because Pavements is a prankish film about a prankish band doesn’t make it any less deeply heartfelt. It’s one for the fans – and we are legion.
Read - 6.3 Slant MagazineBrad Hanford
Even if it’s not quite as insightful as it hopes, Perry’s humorously Cubist portrait finds a fitting balance between reverence and mischievousness.
Read - 6.0 The New YorkerRichard Brody
The resulting film is a kaleidoscopically shifting—and dazzling—collage of elements that have their irony built in and that, jammed together, meld intense sincerity with self-parody (above all, Perry’s own) in an artificial artifact that nonetheless proves more authentic than a plain and unadorned recording.
Read - 4.0 The GuardianPeter Bradshaw
Intriguingly, but finally a bit frustratingly, Perry is running four ideas at once, a kind of cine-quadriptych with the plurality signalled by the title.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Pavements
- What score does Pavements have?
- The critics, 7.8 on average from 24 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Pavements?
- The highest score is Roger Ebert’s (10) and the lowest The Guardian’s (4.0).