Reviews
Shiva Baby
Directed by Emma Seligman · starring Rachel Sennott, Fred Melamed and Polly Draper
- 28 from the press
Shiva Baby: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 7.9 from 28 outlets
- 10 Roger EbertMonica Castillo
As a team, Seligman and Sennott share a spot-on sense of comedic timing, knowing just when to throw in the next cutting remark, eye roll, or fake smile. They hit bullseye each and every time, all the way to the credits.
Read - 10 ConsequenceLauren J. Coates
Paced to perfection and grounded by a magnetic leading performance, Shiva Baby is as painfully awkward as it is impossible to look away from.
Read - 9.1 The Film StageChristopher Schobert
Shiva Baby is a blast of energy and from its first moment to its last Seligman finds the right balance. There is genuine suspense, if not horror; the score, by Ariel Marx, could just as easily fit a summer camp slasher flick. But the greatest feeling for the audience––after discomfort––is excitement.
Read - 9.0 Paste MagazineIsaac Feldberg
Marvelously uncomfortable and cringe-inducingly hilarious, Emma Seligman’s Shiva Baby rides a fine line between comedy and horror that perfectly suits its premise—and feels immediately in step with its protagonist, the college-aged Danielle.
Read - 9.0 VultureHelen Shaw
a perfectly engineered and performed piece of comic cringe.
Read - 9.0 New York TimesJason Bailey
It’s rare for a film to simultaneously balance such wildly divergent tones, to interweave big laughs with gut-wrenching discomfort, but Seligman pulls it off.
Read - 8.3 The A.V. ClubKatie Rife
The style of humor in Shiva Baby can best be described as “sex-positive cringe,” in which the secondhand embarrassment comes less from the sexual situations themselves than our heroine’s collision with polite, conservative society.
Read - 8.3 Original-CinLinda Barnard
Seligman’s tight script landed her on Variety’s list of 10 Screenwriters to Watch for 2020. She uses classic Jewish humour and archetypal characters here that echo 1960s comedy albums and TV sitcoms but freshens it with Generation Z angst and a cascade of emotional pileups.
Read - 8.0 VarietyTomris Laffly
Having grown up in a tight-knit Jewish community herself, Seligman tightly orchestrates it all with loving cultural specificity and nuance, working her satirical muscles to a thrilling extent.
Read - 8.0 The Hollywood ReporterJon Frosch
Anchoring it all is Sennott, deploying a stealthy, low-key timing that’s perfectly suited to a character still struggling to figure out, and get comfortable with, who she is. The actress makes you lean in, her face a frequently blank canvas animated by sporadic squiggles of wit, neediness, resentment and longing that recede almost as soon as they appear.
Read - 8.0 EmpireAlex Godfrey
A perfectly painted portrait that also makes for sharp social commentary, this just goes to show what you can do with a tiny budget but a huge amount of talent.
Read - 8.0 CineVueChristopher Machell
Shiva Baby is ostensibly a comedy yet has all the tension of a thriller. At its most emotionally fraught, it uses the visual and aural grammar of horror cinema.
Read - 8.0 The TelegraphRobbie Collin
Seligman’s command of the flow and swell of comic tension is thrillingly intuitive – she knows exactly when to let it well up, and when to pop it for maximum effect.
Read - 8.0 La NaciónAlejandro Lingenti
And it is the fabulous sensitivity of its lead actress that draws us completely into that journey with an uncertain destination.
Read - 8.0 Página/12Ezequiel Boetti
Shiva Baby owns its insecurities, speaking from the doubts and struggles of a young woman facing an adult world far rougher and more unstable than she was told it would be.
Read - 8.0 Letras LibresFernanda Solórzano
Skilfully, Seligman makes the viewer live through embarrassing, claustrophobic situations while building empathy for her protagonist.
Read - 7.5 SlashfilmJason Gorber
Sullen, sarcastic, silly and seductive at various times, the film manages to walk a high-wire act of tone, making the act of mourning the least miserable part of the family gathering.
Read - 7.5 IndiewireJude Dry
“Shiva Baby” blends a claustrophobic Jewish humor with a sexy premise to deliver a lively debut.
Read - 7.5 Slant MagazineDavid Robb
Emma Seligman’s film effectively builds tension from what is a relatively familiar, low-key scenario.
Read - 7.5 Movie NationRoger Moore
Rare is the comedy that seems to make time stand still. But for 77 cringeworthy and hilarious minutes, that’s what writer-director Emma Seligman pulls off with “Shiva Baby.”
Read - 7.5 The Boston GlobeTy Burr
From its title on down to the rugelach, “Shiva Baby” is an instant classic in the Jewish comedy of mortification, a genre that combines hilarity, anxiety, resentment and schmaltz.
Read - 7.5 Entertainment WeeklyLeah Greenblatt
Enter Shiva at your own risk then: a hell of Danielle's own making maybe, but still a witty, jittery trip.
Read - 7.5 LarsenOnFilmJosh Larsen
Shiva Baby has a comic claustrophobia that almost makes you choke, so intense is its depiction of familial/traditional walls closing in on its main character.
Read - 7.0 El Comercio (Perú)Sebastián Pimentel
“Shiva Baby” (2020) is the calling card of Canadian filmmaker Emma Seligman, who, with her lead actress Rachel Sennott, pulls off a powerful black comedy, somewhere between a post-adolescent plea and a contemporary portrait of a woman.
Read - 6.7 The Austin ChronicleRichard Whittaker
Seligman’s script will strike a sharp chord in anyone that has run into overly-complicated situations at a family gathering (i.e., just about everyone). It feels like a hurdy-gurdy that is just enough put of tune to leave you uneasy, a sensation of queasiness further unbalanced by Ariel Marx’s discordant, scratchy, string-and-timpani soundtrack.
Read - 6.0 Los Angeles TimesGary Goldstein
Unfortunately, writer-director Emma Seligman’s “Shiva Baby,” despite its thematic acuity, loopy vitality and committed acting, doesn’t add up to enough in its too-brief 72 minutes (plus end credits) to warrant all the cross-wired mayhem that gets us over the movie’s dubious finish line.
Read - 6.0 The GuardianPeter Bradshaw
The film is maybe a little callow, but it’s an undoubtedly impressive and accomplished debut.
Read - 5.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer
The script leans on so very many clichés that at times the film feels like a satirical sketch out of Saturday Night Live.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Shiva Baby
- What score does Shiva Baby have?
- The critics, 7.9 on average from 28 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Shiva Baby?
- The highest score is Roger Ebert’s (10) and the lowest Micropsia’s (5.0).