Reviews
Swallow
Directed by Carlo Mirabella-Davis · starring Haley Bennett, Austin Stowell and Denis O'Hare
- 27 from the press
Swallow: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.9 from 27 outlets
- 10 The PlaylistLena Wilson
This unpredictable film is a staggering accomplishment in its storytelling, visuals, and performance — most especially due to Bennett, whose performative vapidity engenders laugh as often as it does gasps.
Read - 9.0 Film ThreatLorry Kikta
Mirabella-Davis somehow perfectly captures a woman's perspective on the twisted series of events that leads Hunter to where she lands by the end of the film.
Read - 8.8 Roger EbertJustine Smith
“Swallow” draws on how feminine perfection can so often be associated with self-destructive behavior.
Read - 8.3 The Film StageJared Mobarak
Inspired by his grandmother’s institutionalization for OCD and propelled by his own experiences having identified as both genders during his lifetime, writer/director Carlo Mirabella-Davis’ fictional feature debut Swallow provides its lead an escape through pica.
Read - 8.0 Screen DailyStephen Whitty
Carefully made and perfectly acted, it’s a real accomplishment for director Carlo Mirabella-Davis, although likely to find its most appreciative audiences in arthouses.
Read - 8.0 Los Angeles TimesKimber Myers
“Swallow” is difficult viewing at times, but it’s psychologically rich and always feels genuine, even in its gorgeously stylized approach to the interior life of its complex protagonist.
Read - 8.0 Time OutGreer McNally
Denis O’Hare delivers a heart-stopping performance as Hunter’s unlikely father figure, but this is Bennett’s show. She is luminous and her journey from beautiful, broken housewife to clear-headed woman, grabbing handfuls of soil from a parking lot to snack on later, is thrilling. It’s a role you can imagine a young Isabelle Huppert playing, and there’s no higher praise than that.
Read - 8.0 El PaísJavier Ocaña
Carlo Mirabella-Davis’s second feature, Swallow is all of these at once, perhaps a little muddled at points in the story, but ultimately consistent with a way of making films far removed from any formula.
Read - 8.0 El PeriódicoNando Salvà
As a result, the film manages to be terrifying without wallowing in gruesome images, letting the questions surrounding the disorder plunge us into unease.
Read - 8.0 Otros CinesDiego Batlle
I would even say that, beyond a certain moralizing streak that surfaces in the resolution, this is a very careful, stylized, clever mise-en-scène, intelligent in its critique of the miseries of the upper class and of the often too understanding, condescending and even submissive place of the traditional woman.
Read - 7.8 The Austin ChronicleJenny Nulf
It’s a film with women in mind, and one that does not judge their choices when it comes to the health of their own bodies and their own minds.
Read - 7.5 IndiewireDavid Ehrlich
While he might not possess Chantal Akerman’s visionary patience, or exhibit Todd Haynes’ singular talent for mining horror from metaphor, Mirabella-Davis has crafted a sharp and surprising modern fable around a woman whose environment has been weaponized against her since birth.
Read - 7.5 Slant MagazineChuck Bowen
Fortunately for the film, Carlo Mirabella-Davis continually springs scenes that either transcend or justify his preaching.
Read - 7.5 Movie NationRoger Moore
There’s a touch of “The Invisible Man” to this unsettling story of the misery of being married to a cruel control freak. But “Swallow,” for all its People Magazine psychoanalysis, is harrowing in different ways and gripping in its myopia. All Hunter has is this mania for “control” of one thing in her life — what she puts in her mouth. All we have is worry over her mental health, and discomfort in confronting it.
Read - 7.5 New York PostSara Stewart
Bennett, who’s been largely off the radar for a while, is heartbreaking and, eventually, fierce as her character begins to crave change.
Read - 7.5 The A.V. ClubKatie Rife
Those sins, along with Bennett’s performance, are what make Swallow more than just a beautifully shot freak show—though the visuals don’t hurt either.
Read - 7.5 The Washington PostAnn Hornaday
Bennett claims her own form of autonomy with the movie itself, which could be read as an actress’s decision to stop hoping for good scripts to arrive over the transom and make her own luck.
Read - 7.0 VarietyPeter Debruge
But, as in such Alfred Hitchcock classics as “Spellbound” and “Marnie,” with their facile psychoanalytic interpretations of compulsive and/or hysterical behavior, the approach can be quite effective in revealing the gender dynamics of the times.
Read - 7.0 VultureAlison Willmore
But while The Invisible Man was built around its clever set pieces rather than its characters, Swallow is led by its protagonist’s mental and emotional state. It takes place in a landscape that’s largely internal — but that’s territory that can be just as filled with darkness and dread as a forbidding mansion.
Read - 7.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer
Closer to a European-style auteur thriller (there is something “Germanic” in its execution) than to a traditional American genre film, SWALLOW is a disturbing journey into the mysteries of the human mind.
Read - 5.0 The WrapCandice Frederick
There are really two contending films inside “Swallow” that, if given the opportunity and the space to do so, could have been fascinating as separate entities.
Read - 5.0 New York TimesKristen Yoonsoo Kim
Given how nauseating it is to watch Hunter perform increasingly perilous acts of self-harm in her prison of a mansion, neither the payoff nor the psychology behind her actions makes Swallow an illuminating enough addition to the woman-on-the-verge-of-a-nervous-breakdown genre.
Read - 5.0 The Boston GlobeTy Burr
The film’s greatest strength is its lead actress, Haley Bennett, who’s on camera for almost the entire running time and who portrays a desperately lonely woman’s journey through self-destruction toward something like sanity.
Read - 5.0 The Globe and MailBarry Hertz
This is a movie that cries out for attention, in ways both admirable and grating.
Read - 5.0 Decine21José María Aresté
An unhealthy film. A weird little one. One of those that set out to make the viewer uncomfortable from minute one.
Read - 2.5 San Francisco ChronicleG. Allen Johnson
Because there’s nary a situation that seems reality-based and uncontrived in this movie that has all the subtlety of a sledgehammer, filled with over-the-top cardboard characters that seem sneered upon by their creator. If Mirabella-Davis doesn’t believe in his characters, why should we?
Read - 1.0 The Hollywood ReporterCaryn James
The idea is cartoonish in its essence but the pic is shot and played with such straight-faced realism that Swallow becomes utterly ridiculous.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Swallow
- What score does Swallow have?
- The critics, 6.9 on average from 27 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Swallow?
- The highest score is The Playlist’s (10) and the lowest The Hollywood Reporter’s (1.0).