The Lost Valentine: cast and crew

• Darnell Martin Also in Cadillac Records (2008)

Actors

13

Crew

3

Youngest at release

20 yearsMeghann Fahy

Eldest at release

89 yearsBetty White

• Jennifer Love Hewitt Susan Allison 31 at release Also in Tropic Thunder (2008)
• Betty White † 2021 Caroline Thomas 89 at release Also in The Lorax (2012)
• Sean Faris Lucas Thomas 28 at release Also in Pearl Harbor (2001)
• Billy Magnussen Neil Thomas 25 at release Also in Aladdin (2019)
• Meghann Fahy Young Caroline 20 at release Also in Drop (2025)
• Nadia Dajani Julie Oliver 45 at release Also in On the Rocks (2020)
• Will Chase Andrew Hawthorne 40 at release Also in Shaft (2000)
• Mike Pniewski Craig Warren 49 at release Also in Richard Jewell (2019)
• Tom Nowicki Glenn Billings Also in Flight (2012)

The whole cast 13

1. Jennifer Love Hewitt Susan Allison
2. Betty White Caroline Thomas
3. Sean Faris Lucas Thomas
4. Billy Magnussen Neil Thomas
5. Meghann Fahy Young Caroline
6. Nadia Dajani Julie Oliver
7. Will Chase Andrew Hawthorne
8. Mike Pniewski Craig Warren
9. Tom Nowicki Glenn Billings
10. Andy Stahl Senator Max Irving
11. Gregory Alan Williams Chaplain Richard Brady
12. Robert Pralgo David Oliver
13. Wilbur Fitzgerald Conductor

Production companies

Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions

Who plays Susan Allison in The Lost Valentine?

Jennifer Love Hewitt plays Susan Allison.

Who plays Caroline Thomas in The Lost Valentine?

Betty White plays Caroline Thomas.

Who plays Lucas Thomas in The Lost Valentine?

Sean Faris plays Lucas Thomas.

Who plays Neil Thomas in The Lost Valentine?

Billy Magnussen plays Neil Thomas.

Who plays Young Caroline in The Lost Valentine?

Meghann Fahy plays Young Caroline.

Who plays Julie Oliver in The Lost Valentine?

Nadia Dajani plays Julie Oliver.

Who directed The Lost Valentine?

Darnell Martin.

How many actors are in The Lost Valentine?

13 actors are credited, and 3 people in the crew.

• Tom Nowicki and Mike Pniewski have worked together on 2 other films: The Case for Christ (2017) and Dolphin Tale (2011).

• Andy Stahl and Mike Pniewski had already worked together on 2 films: A Time to Kill (1996) and The People vs. Larry Flynt (1996).

• Sean Faris and Tom Nowicki had already worked together on one film: Never back down (2008).

• Wilbur Fitzgerald and Billy Magnussen have worked together on one other film: The East (2012).

• Andy Stahl and Robert Pralgo had already worked together on one film: The Blind Side (2009).

• Wilbur Fitzgerald and Robert Pralgo have worked together on one other film: Sully (2016).

• With the most films on MovieNCo: Billy Magnussen (25), Wilbur Fitzgerald (24) and Mike Pniewski (19).

• The cast’s average age at release is 44 (of the 11 actors whose birth date we know).