Reviews
The Roundup: Punishment
Original title범죄도시 4
starring Dong-Seok Ma, Lee Beom-soo and Derek Chouinard
- 14 from the press
The Roundup: Punishment: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.9 from 14 outlets
- 8.0 VarietyJessica Kiang
“The Roundup: Punishment” minimizes unnecessary originality, while gloriously maximizing the opportunities for Lee to crack wise, or look aggrieved and a little bored, as though he’s just remembered he needs to do laundry, all while his sledgehammer forearms land a flurry of punches so rapid their recipients, often quite literally, do not know what hit them. This, truly, is cinema.
Read - 8.0 Elements of MadnessDouglas Davidson
[The fourth outing] looks to tackle digital crime with the very specific humor, thoughtfulness, and tactical violence fans of Detective Ma expect.
Read - 8.0 NYC Movie GuruAvi Offer
Don Lee reprises his role as Ma Seok-do and knocks it out of the ballpark with his charismatic performance yet again.
Read - 7.5 The Chinese CinemaSean Gilman
The man with the cinder block fists is back, and this time he's learning what the internet is.
Read - 7.5 Spectrum CultureChristian Valentin
The Roundup: Punishment refreshingly evokes the movie star-dominated era of yore, where a lead and their distinct qualities could elevate formula beyond familiarity into unique entertainment.
Read - 7.0 Screen DailyWendy Ide
And while The Roundup: Punishment may not win over new audiences, it is unlikely to disappoint its fanbase: it’s a robustly entertaining romp starring Ma Dong-seok (aka Don Lee), reprising the role of “Beast Cop” Detective Ma Seok-du and clobbering some justice into a selection of snivelling wrongdoers with his piledriver fists.
Read - 7.0 MoviementariosFuranu
Moreover, the charisma of Ma Dong-seok, with his imposing physique and his ability to combine brutality with tenderness and humour, remains the cornerstone.
Read - 7.0 Ramen Para DosAlejo Correa
Action scenes that keep working thanks to their frantic pace and an exceptional use of camera and cutting, exploding in a final, fiery fight that surprises with its cramped space and the force of its blows.
Read - 7.0 Loud and Clear ReviewsJustin Kim
For one, the film's action is actually a lot stronger than I expected.
Read - 7.0 Bounding Into ComicsChris Sawin
With its swift action, decent story, and entertaining characters, The Roundup: Punishment continues to solidify the best string of action films most people don't even know about.
Read - 7.0 Asynchronous MediaChristopher Cross
The Roundup: Punishment takes things to new heights in its pursuit of criminals hiding behind computers.
Read - 6.0 The Straits TimesWhang Yee Ling
The star-driven action genre piece is sheer formula, as comforting in his ever invincible strength as it is tension-free for the same reason.
Read - 5.0 Roger EbertSimon Abrams
It’s not hard to see the appeal of “The Roundup: Punishment” given the technical polish and formulaic conventions that keep this series chugging along. But Lee still deserves better dialogue—“I made someone a promise. To punish you.”—and better jokes, too.
Read - 4.0 In Review OnlineJoshua Polanski
Four films into any series, you either change or die, and the copaganda finally outruns the action choreography in the fourth installment in The Roundup series.
Read
Questions about the reviews of The Roundup: Punishment
- What score does The Roundup: Punishment have?
- The critics, 6.9 on average from 14 reviews.
- What do the critics say about The Roundup: Punishment?
- The highest score is Variety’s (8.0) and the lowest In Review Online’s (4.0).