Reviews
Vanguard
Original title急先锋
Directed by Stanley Tong · starring Jackie Chan, Yang Yang and Eyad Hourani
- 16 from the press
Vanguard: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 4.1 from 16 outlets
- 6.0 Film ThreatAlex Saveliev
There are worse ways to pass 90 minutes for those willing to disregard the film’s numerous, glaring flaws. Call it a Chinese Mission Impossible, minus Ethan Hunt’s budget and brains.
Read - 5.8 Original-CinThom Ernst
Let’s be clear: Vanguard is not a great film. Arguably, it’s one of the lesser successes in the Stanley Tong/Jackie Chan oeuvre. But even if Vanguard tilts the scales slightly lower than the duos earlier efforts (Vanguard is their ninth collaboration), it still doesn’t dip low enough to be a failure.
Read - 5.0 San Francisco ChronicleMick LaSalle
For the most part, this film has the disadvantages of Chinese action films, without the advantages. That is, it overdoes the action and it’s short on character, without attaining the manic, wild heights of Hong Kong cinema of the 1980s and early ’90s. Still, it’s nice to see Chan once again in a Chinese environment.
Read - 5.0 Roger EbertSimon Abrams
The movie’s off-putting and constantly foregrounded political agenda wouldn’t be so unpleasant if the action scenes were more plentiful and/or thrilling. They aren’t.
Read - 5.0 New York PostJohnny Oleksinski
Of course, nobody watches a Jackie Chan movie for the sophisticated plots or deep characters. They come for the martial arts. But those, too, settle for being not much more than a kick in the park.
Read - 4.0 The Hollywood ReporterElizabeth Kerr
If nothing else, director Stanley Tong and martial arts superstar Jackie Chan’s latest effort, Vanguard, proves the law of diminishing returns. Not too long ago a Chan film guaranteed an entertaining time at the movies and heaps of awe at what the human body could endure. Now? Not so much.
Read - 4.0 Screen DailyJohn Berra
More of branding exercise than a fully fledged star vehicle, this fast moving but instantly forgettable adventure allows Chan to participate in the set pieces while ceding the really strenuous activity to his up-and-coming co-stars.
Read - 4.0 The Austin ChronicleMatthew Monagle
All of this culminates in a film that is equal parts silly and nationalist. If you find yourself nostalgic for the bloodless mode of America vs. The World action movies that populated the 1990s, then Vanguard is for you. And if you’re a Jackie Chan completist, the mediocre nature of the film is at least partially offset by his heartfelt rendition of the theme song and an A+ collection of outtakes that play over the end credits.
Read - 4.0 New York TimesGlenn Kenny
Tong is not a stickler for verisimilitude. Hence, this movie’s ridiculous computer generated lions; hence also, its solid-gold sports cars.
Read - 4.0 VarietyDennis Harvey
This action spectacular seems hellbent on containing every possible marketable genre element, with no concern for whether they cohere or cancel one another out.
Read - 4.0 The GuardianPeter Bradshaw
The scene with a jetski on the edge of a waterfall deserves points, but this feels disposable: the Chinese New Year is earnestly referenced as part of the film’s strident and faintly humourless patriotism.
Read - 4.0 The ObserverWendy Ide
It’s an unforgivable waste of Jackie Chan, action-movie legend, reduced here to pratfalls and gurning double takes.
Read - 4.0 Martin Cid MagazineMartin Cid
A product with plenty of room for improvement that aims for what can’t be (anymore). It tries so hard to please everyone that it ends up rather lacking in substance.
Read - 2.5 Slant MagazinePat Brown
Stanley Tong’s Vanguard is an unsettling, uncanny reflection of the jingoism that Hollywood has been wrapping in glossy spectacle and exporting to foreign markets for decades.
Read - 2.5 The A.V. ClubIgnatiy Vishnevetsky
But the move from practical stuns to a discount VFX simulacrum (no real cars appear to have been wrecked in any of these chase scenes) has not flattered Tong’s amateurish direction.
Read - 2.0 The TelegraphTim Robey
The general ineptitude is more likely to make you cackle in disbelief.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Vanguard
- What score does Vanguard have?
- The critics, 4.1 on average from 16 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Vanguard?
- The highest score is Film Threat’s (6.0) and the lowest The Telegraph’s (2.0).