Reviews
Brian Banks
Directed by Tom Shadyac · starring Aldis Hodge, Greg Kinnear and Sherri Shepherd
- 17 from the press
Brian Banks: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.0 from 17 outlets
- 8.5 Film ThreatAlan Ng
From a macro level, Brian Banks should just be a social justice film, but as we peer into the life of Banks himself, you’ll see a deeper and more profound story.
Read - 8.0 VarietyPeter Debruge
So, where do Shadyac and Atchison expect audiences to direct their frustration at such a miscarriage of justice? Well, that’s what makes “Brian Banks” special: It is not an angry film, but one that preaches forgiveness in the face of such adversity.
Read - 7.5 The Washington PostAlan Zilberman
On one level, Brian’s story is meant to be inspirational; the real Banks would ultimately go on to play in the NFL. But it is also a painful reminder of how young black people still face overwhelming disadvantages. The film leaves you wondering: What might have happened if Brian hadn’t been a talented linebacker?
- 7.5 Chicago Sun-TimesRichard Roeper
Sure, there are times when we’re aware our emotions are being manipulated — but we’re fine with that, because we want to see, and we expect to see, the heroic underdog triumph against nearly insurmountable odds.
Read - 7.0 The Hollywood ReporterStephen Farber
Hodge’s performance is what keeps Brian Banks on track. He is powerful in scenes of anger, but he may be even better in purely silent moments where his unspoken reactions are eloquent.
Read - 7.0 Los Angeles TimesKenneth Turan
Conventional but effectively so, more tense and involving than might be anticipated as obstacles pile on obstacles, this emotionally affecting story knows enough not to push too hard and reaps the benefits from its relative restraint.
Read - 6.3 Chicago TribuneMichael Phillips
Brian Banks proceeds non-chronologically, toggling between high school years and Banks’ post-prison life. This helps keep the audience on its toes. But it’s the actors who complicate things most fruitfully.
Read - 6.3 Roger EbertChristy Lemire
Playing Banks over the course of more than a decade, Hodge consistently makes the movie compelling, even when it veers toward a safe, faith-based uplift.
Read - 6.0 New York TimesJeannette Catsoulis
Brian Banks isn’t a great movie, but it is a worthwhile one. And if it’s indicative of a new direction for its director, you won’t hear any complaints from me.
Read - 6.0 The Arizona RepublicBill Goodykoontz
It’s Hodge’s portrayal of Banks that elevates the film.
- 6.0 Rolling StonePeter Travers
The proceedings are raised when Hodge is onscreen, using every nuanced look and gesture to jump the hurdles of a banal script and reveal the pain tearing up Banks. Having made a mark in films like Straight Outta Compton and Hidden Figures, and on TV in City on a Hill, Hodge hits new heights of commitment.
Read - 5.0 San Francisco ChronicleMick LaSalle
Despite some real virtues, Brian Banks as a whole, is only a break-even experience.
Read - 5.0 Movie NationRoger Moore
All of which makes “Brian Banks” much more of a mixed bag of a movie than you’d hope. A “broken system” isn’t going to be driven to change by pulled punches like this one.
Read - 4.5 The WrapCandice Frederick
Perhaps the worst thing a film can be, even more so than the binary of good or bad, is forgettable.
Read - 4.2 The A.V. ClubJesse Hassenger
This is a movie that seems utterly convinced that it’s saying something profound, but proves difficult to actually parse.
Read - 4.2 IndiewireKate Erbland
Hodge sells it, just as he sells the rest of an otherwise chintzy film, a Lifetime movie-like drama that falls short of engaging with the many thorny issues it dramatizes.
Read - 3.3 The PlaylistAndrew Bundy
Shadyac’s movie may ask difficult questions about the ills that society grapples with today, but it tackles them in a shallow, facile, sometimes uncomfortably out of touch manner.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Brian Banks
- What score does Brian Banks have?
- The critics, 6.0 on average from 17 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Brian Banks?
- The highest score is Film Threat’s (8.5) and the lowest The Playlist’s (3.3).