Advertising Remove ads
Emily the Criminal poster

Reviews

Emily the Criminal

Directed by John Patton Ford · starring Aubrey Plaza, John Billingsley and Kim Yarbrough

  • 40 from the press

Emily the Criminal: reviews

Reviews

What the critics say average 7.6 from 40 outlets

  • 10 San Francisco ChronicleMick LaSalle It’s a crime movie, but as the title suggests, it’s a personality study, a detailed one that grows in dimension. It’s fascinating to watch Plaza fill in those details. Her face is almost blank, but only almost. We always know what she’s thinking. Read
  • 10 Roger EbertSheila O'Malley This is John Patton Ford’s directorial debut, and it is an extremely impressive piece of work. Read
  • 9.1 IndiewireKate Erbland You always know a Plaza performance will be good, but over the past few years, Plaza has seemed to make it a priority to surprise her audiences with just how good she is. Read
  • 8.8 Movie NationRoger Moore “Emily the Criminal” is the face and voice of not just the summer, but an American generation right now, looking for a break and desperate enough to cross the line if they don’t get it. Read
  • 8.8 Chicago Sun-TimesRichard Roeper Rossi and Plaza make for a sizzling team; we believe every syllable of their dialogue, every development in their relationship. It’s almost criminal, how good these two are together. Read
  • 8.8 ObserverRex Reed At a time when few movies display either a shred of originality or a fresh slant on an old genre, and so many are little more than cookie-cutter derivations of each other, it’s energizing to see something as keenly observed and uniquely competent as Emily the Criminal. It’s a tense and engaging thriller that looks and feels distinctively different. Read
  • 8.5 The WrapKatie Walsh In 95 minutes, Ford unfurls a gritty and suspenseful L.A. noir that also serves to examine the structural issues that uphold wealth inequality in this country. But “Emily the Criminal” isn’t trying to be preachy or political, it’s just authentic, and urgent, and Plaza’s performance keeps the emotional and physical honesty at the forefront. Read
  • 8.3 Entertainment WeeklyLeah Greenblatt Ford imbues his story with a tense, vibrating energy, moving briskly between the breathlessness of a heist thriller and the sharper barbs of social satire. Read
  • 8.3 ColliderRoss Bonaime Emily the Criminal is an excellent example of how to make an effective thriller on a smaller scale. Read
  • 8.3 Original-CinKaren Gordon Emily the Criminal is the debut feature by John Patton Ford, who also wrote the script. He’s done a nice job here of ramping up the tension, without resorting to a lot of overwrought situations or melodrama. He keeps the story small and contained and the camera close on the characters. Read
  • 8.3 The A.V. ClubJack Smart Here Plaza sacrifices her signature irreverence for a bone-deep frustration that feels all too relatable, even ordinary, resulting in the most true-to-life performance of her career. Read
  • 8.3 PolygonKatie Rife As a crime thriller, Emily the Criminal is well-written and absorbingly paced, but it’s Plaza’s fearless work that makes it memorable. Read
  • 8.0 The GuardianBenjamin Lee Ford has a knack for making us sweat without relying on an over-egged score or over-stacked stakes. It’s a genre movie with its feet firmly on the ground, small in scale and tight in focus. Read
  • 8.0 The Hollywood ReporterJohn DeFore A cool, confident debut whose steady build mirrors the increasing stakes faced by its namesake, John Patton Ford’s Emily the Criminal is a nail-biter that makes the most of the tough side Aubrey Plaza has shown in even her most comic performances. Read
  • 8.0 Time OutPhil de Semlyen Plaza, who follows up Black Bear with another darker turn, is great in a role that lets her badass side out for a rampage Read
  • 8.0 Screen DailyTim Grierson The narrative may have familiar contours, but Ford’s close attention to the have-nots’ desire to transcend their circumstances gives the proceedings a gripping emotional undercurrent. Read
  • 8.0 Screen RantMae Abdulbaki Poignant in parts, sharp and thrilling in others, Emily the Criminal satisfyingly delivers on many levels. Read
  • 8.0 Los Angeles TimesJustin Chang Plaza doesn’t have to steal scenes in “Emily the Criminal.” She plays the title role, and nearly every moment — starting with the one where Emily storms out (not for the last time) of a degrading job interview — rightly belongs to her. Read
  • 8.0 VultureAlison Willmore Emily moves among immigrants, fellow ex-cons, and people like Youcef who are striving toward some sort of financial legitimacy, even as she moves in the other direction. But she doesn’t show any sense of commonality with them, only fury that she’s been made to join them, which is the film’s most astringent aspect. Read
  • 8.0 The TelegraphTim Robey Much of the film’s success comes down to Plaza, who has left that deadpan sphinxlike mode of hers some way back in the rear-view mirror. Grit replaces irony, and it’s fascinating to watch her think her way through every predicament here, deftly and in detail, weighing the percentages. Read
  • 8.0 EmpireCatherine Bray An entertaining thriller that also functions as a character study with a dark side, Emily The Criminal is above all else a spectacular argument for casting Aubrey Plaza in as many off-beat and well-written indie movies as she has the time and inclination to appear in. Read
  • 8.0 EspinofPedro Gallego Ford uses the tools of a nervy, electric thriller to keep a firm pulse for much of its 95-minute running time. Read
  • 8.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer EMILY… is a very good crime film that also manages to offer a political view of today's reality (economic and, if you like, feminist too) without underlining or declaiming anything. Read
  • 7.5 The PlaylistGregory Ellwood There are definitely some logical gaps in Ford’s screenplay and perhaps the consequences could be slightly more dangerous (intriguingly, guns barely appear throughout the proceedings), but as a filmmaker, he displays a keen awareness of racking up the tension when necessary and not overdoing it when it’s not. Read
  • 7.5 The Washington PostMichael O'Sullivan A kind of gravitational pull emanates from Aubrey Plaza as the title character in “Emily the Criminal,” a passably diverting crime thriller where, in place of a moral center, Plaza delivers a performance that is entertainingly blackhearted. Read
  • 7.5 Chicago TribuneMichael Phillips Emily the Criminal delves only so far into character on the page, but working from what writer-director Ford gives her, Plaza creates a woman defined by incremental degrees of economic stress and simmering resolve. Read
  • 7.4 The Globe and MailBarry Hertz Ford’s film cannot be entirely discounted – the director knows a star when he sees one, and seems to retroactively contort his screenplay around the talents of Plaza as much as he can. The actress makes Emily’s plight seem relatable, unrelenting and never ever precious. Read
  • 7.0 SlashfilmChris Evangelista Plaza's performance, which grows more desperate and more fierce, is what keeps things going. Tension continually mounts and builds, and writer-director Ford stages several anxiety-ridden set-pieces that inspire a sick-to-your-stomach feeling. Read
  • 7.0 Film ThreatRob Rector The finale of Emily the Criminal does not match the pulse-pounding scenes of her earlier assignments. However, it still manages to work toward a satisfying, logical conclusion while offering a solid critique of the gig economy many Americans face in which fortune is merely a credit card swipe away. Read
  • 7.0 VistazoJorge Tigrero It is thanks to Aubrey Plaza's talent and great acting ability that a script with some flaws manages to hold up and become something memorable. Read
  • 6.7 The Film StageJordan Raup Emily the Criminal keeps up the pace to deliver an entertaining ride but misses the audacity to leave a genuine mark. Read
  • 6.7 The Austin ChronicleJosh Kupecki While turning to a life of crime to get out of debt isn’t the most original concept, Ford’s decision to keep his camera on Emily’s face for most of the film elevates the material, for Plaza’s performance is the draw here. Her Emily is mad as hell and not going to take it anymore, and there’s a steely, unapologetic gaze in those huge brown eyes of hers. Plaza’s trademark twinkle remains, here cast with a crimson hue. Read
  • 6.3 Slant MagazineWes Greene Emily the Criminal may not suffer from didacticism, but it’s almost perversely at its most volcanic when it promises to blossom into a study of a generation’s financial difficulties than when it’s capturing a descent into crime in Dardennian fashion. Read
  • 6.3 The Boston GlobeMark Feeney What “Emily the Criminal” really is is a character study; and this is where Plaza comes in. She’s the really good thing the movie has going for it. Over the course of 96 minutes, Emily will do some surprising things. Plaza makes them seem as natural as swiping a credit card, and in both senses of the verb. Read
  • 6.0 The New YorkerRichard Brody He creates a title character, played by Aubrey Plaza, who seems to carry a world with her, and he sets the action in a shadow realm of workaday grifters which emerges in fascinating detail. Yet that core of cinematic power gives rise to a modestly engaging but undistinguished, mundane movie, one that speaks as much to the givens of film production as to Ford’s own ambivalent achievement. Read
  • 6.0 Rolling StoneK. Austin Collins As a social tract, Emily the Criminal is more impassioned than wise. As a thriller, it fares better — in that case, no one’s asking for wisdom. Read
  • 5.8 ConsequenceClint Worthington There’s a lot to sink your teeth into with Emily the Criminal, between its strong Plaza turn and a pitch-black moral core that refreshingly commits to the bit. But outside of those devilish comforts, a lot of Ford’s debut is frustratingly thin, more concerned with giving Plaza plenty of opportunities to bore through the screen with her eyes in extreme close-up than in really breaking down her psychology and the perverse romance at its center. Read
  • 5.5 Paste MagazineJacob Oller While Plaza continues to make her case as a versatile A-lister capable of leading the more complex version of this kind of heist film, Emily the Criminal is a little like an initiation that never needed to happen. Her bonafides are proven. But it still stands as another showcase for her, as she shines even through its uninspired racket. Read
  • 5.0 VarietyAmy Nicholson Despite the fact that the camera rarely backs away from studying Plaza’s wary eyes and tense mouth in close-up, this character piece feels as distanced from its taciturn subject as if it was merely monitoring her on security camera. Read
  • 5.0 The Wall Street JournalKyle Smith Caper movies rely heavily on how well they build plausibility into the doings of professional scam artists, but Emily the Criminal scores poorly on that front.
Advertising Remove ads

Questions about the reviews of Emily the Criminal

What score does Emily the Criminal have?
The critics, 7.6 on average from 40 reviews.
What do the critics say about Emily the Criminal?
The highest score is San Francisco Chronicle’s (10) and the lowest The Wall Street Journal’s (5.0).
Advertising Remove ads