Reviews
Infidel
Directed by Cyrus Nowrasteh · starring Jim Caviezel, Claudia Karvan and Stelio Savante
- 12 from the press
Infidel: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 5.5 from 12 outlets
- 7.5 The Independent CriticRichard Propes
Nowrasteh's storytelling wisely avoids histrionics, instead trusting the power of the story itself and the ability of the actors to drive it all home.
Read - 7.0 CinemagaviaIrene Abecia Navarro
Entertaining and engaging, it knows how to hold the viewer's attention.
Read - 6.7 Bowling Green Daily NewsMicheal Compton
"Infidel" is clunky at times and a bit heavy-handed, but it manages to find its footing in the second half. The result is a thriller that definitely could have been better but is still good enough to be worth your time.
Read - 6.3 Roger EbertSheila O'Malley
Agenda-driven films make for dreary viewing and “Infidel” is never dreary. Aided by excellent performances across the board by its international cast, “Infidel” works best when it’s an old-fashioned thriller.
Read - 6.3 Aisle SeatMike McGranaghan
Plenty to admire can be found in the film, yet the flaws prove frustrating in how they undermine the strengths. There's a potentially powerful story here about American citizens unjustly held captive in places like Iran. Nowrasteh doesn't quite find it.
Read - 6.0 VarietyPeter Debruge
Although Caviezel’s character is meant to stand in for all Americans unjustly imprisoned by the Iranian government (shown here to be in league with extremists), it would be irresponsible to take the film’s “inspired by true events” claim too seriously. As action movie premises go, that doesn’t mean it’s not satisfying to watch Liz and several co-conspirators raid the facility in an attempt to liberate Doug and all those unjustly detained political prisoners.
Read - 6.0 Rachel's ReviewsRachel Wagner
The first part of Infidel with Doug speaking and getting over to Cairo is very clunky, and I thought for sure I was going frown-worthy on it. However, once the movie gets into full rescue mode it became a lot more palatable.
Read - 5.0 Susan GrangerSusan Granger
Ostensibly about human rights abuses and corruption, the concept defeats itself.
Read - 5.0 Screen It!Jim Judy
With more work on such matters, this could have been a riveting political-religious thriller. As it stands, it's okay, but often feels like just a continuation of Caviezel's on-screen religious persecution.
Read - 4.0 Common Sense MediaJeffrey M. Anderson
This "inspired by true events" drama is presented in a blandly impersonal, uninspired manner, with wobbly, uneven filmmaking, a dull lead character, and a mixed collection of messages about faith.
Read - 4.0 Reel ReviewsFrank Wilkins
But ultimately, this ripped-from-the-headlines spy thriller spreads itself too thin and never musters up enough bite to become the powerful story it sets out to be.
Read - 2.0 Catholic News ServiceKurt Jensen
The movie is intended to reinforce existing ideas rather than change minds or explain in any detail how sectarian conflicts arise. Nuance is thus entirely absent, and the focus remains on extremism overcoming morality.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Infidel
- What score does Infidel have?
- The critics, 5.5 on average from 12 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Infidel?
- The highest score is The Independent Critic’s (7.5) and the lowest Catholic News Service’s (2.0).