Advertising Remove ads
It's a Wonderful Knife poster

Reviews

It's a Wonderful Knife

Directed by Tyler MacIntyre · starring Joel McHale, Justin Long and Jessica McLeod

  • 15 from the press

It's a Wonderful Knife: reviews

Reviews

What the critics say average 5.5 from 15 outlets

  • 9.0 Film ThreatMichael Talbot-Haynes It's A Wonderful Knife is one of those pictures that is so surprisingly good you wish you had seen it in a theater. Plus, this is one spiffy-looking picture. Read
  • 8.8 Roger EbertRobert Daniels “It’s A Wonderful Knife” has plenty of attributes—charm, blood, and angst—that should fit right in at any family holiday gathering. Read
  • 7.5 SlashfilmMatt Donato "It's A Wonderful Knife" might make its points with steel blades, but that doesn't negate the saccharine earnestness that assures this one as a new Christmas horror favorite with a heart three sizes bigger than you'd expect. Read
  • 6.3 Chicago Sun-TimesRichard Roeper As you’d expect, “It’s a Wonderful Knife” is filled with blood-spattered twists on holiday movie tropes. Unfortunately, there are few surprises and only a handful of genuine scares, and the film suffers from subpar lighting and occasionally clunky editing. It’s a “Knife” in need of some sharpening. Read
  • 6.0 IGNKatie Rife Solid fundamentals make It’s a Wonderful Knife an enjoyable Christmas slasher, although not as inspired as the writer Michael Kennedy’s previous work. Read
  • 6.0 EmpireBen Travis Sometimes cheap but largely cheerful, this is a fun stocking-filler for horror fans — with plenty of heart to pump all that blood. Read
  • 6.0 Cinéfilo SerialSami Schuster The film at hand blends this sort of homage to, or echo of, the American classic with the slasher genre to give us an entertaining story with some interesting twists and moments that tug at the emotions. Read
  • 5.8 ColliderIsabella Soares While often bloody, It's a Wonderful Knife is never too spooky for non-horror fans and never too focused on a cheesy love story for those watching the film for its gory delights. There is a little bit for everyone here, making for a pleasant enough viewing experience for this holiday season. Read
  • 5.0 The Austin ChronicleRichard Whittaker Clunky horror in-jokes, like a heavy-handed Scream nod in the name of Winnie’s aunt (Isabelle), feel labored, and it’s all plagued by the same unevenness that afflicted director Tyler MacIntyre’s Tragedy Girls: The gore and the comedy are well-executed, but the timing is off. Read
  • 5.0 VarietyJ. Kim Murphy The genre slant promised by the title seems to be less of a tonal responsibility than an excuse to abruptly break out into the occasional suspense set piece. Read
  • 4.2 IndiewireAlison Foreman It’s queer and contemporary — a decent addition to an already lengthy Christmas horror movie marathon that can edge out 1997’s “Jack Frost” but doesn’t come close to touching “Gremlins” or even “Krampus.” Read
  • 4.0 The GuardianCatherine Bray It’s a Wonderful Knife is diverting enough to start with, as the plot clicks efficiently into motion with the requisite stabbings and impalings. Unfortunately, there’s not enough fuel in the engine – the characters don’t have quite enough to do, we can’t care quite enough about them, and the world-building is nearly-but-not-quite convincing. Read
  • 3.4 Paste MagazineUrsula Muñoz S. Festive horror is a notorious subgenre, with last year’s runaway success Violent Night scratching this itch for many—to say nothing of classics like 1974’s Black Christmas. It’s A Wonderful Knife sports an equally clever parody title, but has little else going for it, coasting on the premise of Frank Capra’s classic and failing to stand out among its predecessors. Read
  • 3.0 Los Angeles TimesJen Yamato Try as it does to mash slasher and Christmas picture together into some kind of a yuletide “Scream,” “It’s a Wonderful Knife” so badly miscalculates both genres that you count down the minutes, wishing for a guardian angel to save its likable young stars from the movie they’re stuck in. Read
  • 2.5 Movie NationRoger Moore “It’s a Wonderful Knife” doesn’t just slash through our expectations about what we’re going to see. It stumbles in managing the basics, starting with “Must make some kind of sense, surreal or otherwise.” Read
Advertising Remove ads

Questions about the reviews of It's a Wonderful Knife

What score does It's a Wonderful Knife have?
The critics, 5.5 on average from 15 reviews.
What do the critics say about It's a Wonderful Knife?
The highest score is Film Threat’s (9.0) and the lowest Movie Nation’s (2.5).
Advertising Remove ads