Film · 2023
It's a Wonderful Knife
Directed by Tyler MacIntyre · starring Joel McHale, Justin Long and Jessica McLeod
- 5.5 Critics15 reviews
Synopsis
In 'It's a Wonderful Life', George Bailey found out how much his town needed him. 'It's a Wonderful Knife' turns the idea around with a knife in its hand. It's a Christmas slasher played for laughs, directed by Tyler MacIntyre in 2023 from a script by Michael Kennedy, who wrote 'Freaky'. What its heroine gets to see is how many deaths she prevented.
In Angel Falls, Winnie Carruthers's Christmas Eve ends badly. A killer in a white mask, known as the Angel, murders her best friend and almost gets her brother before she puts a stop to him. A year on, the town has moved past it. Winnie hasn't. She's still grieving, her family would rather not talk about it, and at a party she finds out her boyfriend has been cheating on her.
Alone on a bridge, under the northern lights, she wishes she'd never been born. The wish is granted. In the Angel Falls she walks back into, nobody knows her, not even her parents, and since she was never there to stop him, the Angel is still killing. Her only ally is Bernie, a school outcast who agrees to believe her story. To get her life back she'll have to stop the killer a second time.
Jane Widdop, from 'Yellowjackets', plays Winnie, with Jess McLeod as Bernie. Justin Long is Henry Waters, the businessman who wants half the town for a shopping mall, and Joel McHale of 'Community' is Winnie's father. Katharine Isabelle and William B. Davis, the Cigarette Smoking Man from 'The X-Files', also appear. It was shot in Vancouver in spring 2023 and opened in US cinemas on 10 November, three weeks before it reached Shudder. Reviews were mixed: some enjoyed the conceit, others felt the film didn't make enough of it.
Where to watch It's a Wonderful Knife
All the optionsAvailable now in the UK:
Availability checked on 16 November 2026.
The essentials
- Runtime
- 87 min1 hour and 27 minutes
- Box office
- $1.3mworldwide
- How long is It's a Wonderful Knife?
- 1 hour and 27 minutes (87 minutes).
- When was It's a Wonderful Knife released in the UK?
- It was released in the UK on 30 November 2023.
- Who directed It's a Wonderful Knife?
- Tyler MacIntyre.
- Who is in It's a Wonderful Knife?
- It stars Joel McHale, Justin Long, Jessica McLeod and Katharine Isabelle.
- Where can I watch It's a Wonderful Knife?
- In the UK it is available with the Prime Video channel on Shudder and to rent on Apple TV.
- How much did It's a Wonderful Knife make?
- It took $1.3 million worldwide.
Cast
Full cast (8)-
Joel McHale David Carruthers
-
Justin Long Henry Waters
-
Jessica McLeod Bernie Simon
-
Katharine Isabelle Gale Prescott
-
Erin Boyes Judy Carruthers
-
William B. Davis Roger Evans
-
Jude Wilson Art Boy
- Director
- Tyler MacIntyre
Photos and posters
All 4 photosReviews
All 15 reviewsWhat the critics say average 5.5 from 15 outlets
- 9.0 Film ThreatMichael Talbot-Haynes
It's A Wonderful Knife is one of those pictures that is so surprisingly good you wish you had seen it in a theater. Plus, this is one spiffy-looking picture.
Read - 5.8 ColliderIsabella Soares
While often bloody, It's a Wonderful Knife is never too spooky for non-horror fans and never too focused on a cheesy love story for those watching the film for its gory delights. There is a little…
Read - 2.5 Movie NationRoger Moore
“It’s a Wonderful Knife” doesn’t just slash through our expectations about what we’re going to see. It stumbles in managing the basics, starting with “Must make some kind of sense, surreal or…
Read
Box office
Weekend by weekend- Worldwide $1.3m
Soundtrack
All 22 songs- Sweetest Christmas DayHousequake Housequake, Delphine Blanc, Mowave Mowave
- Dancing in the Snowand Dom James, Roger Webb
- Kiss Me Under MistletoeTHE WELL PENNIES
- Christmas My Old FriendJames Kilbane, Julian Emery, Adam Noble
If you liked It's a Wonderful Knife
-
6.4 The Nun II 2023 same genre -
7.2 The Conjuring: Last Rites 2025 same genre -
6.8 Presence 2024 same genre -
Stranger Things TV series · 2016–2026 same genre -
5.9 Never Let Go 2024 same genre -
6.3 Smile 2022 same genre -
7.7 28 Years Later 2025 same genre -
The Walking Dead TV series · 2010–2022 same genre -
6.4 The Monkey 2025 same genre -
6.1 Cobweb 2023 same genre -
Me and You and Everyone We Know 2005 same genre -
The Simpsons TV series · 1989– same genre