Reviews
Our Friend
Directed by Gabriela Cowperthwaite · starring Jason Segel, Isabella Kai Rice and Violet McGraw
- 21 from the press
Our Friend: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.2 from 21 outlets
- 8.0 Los Angeles TimesGary Goldstein
The film absorbingly shuttles back and forth in time, tracking key moments in the trio’s lives that not only illuminate their pasts but effectively prepare us for who Matt, Nicole and Dane become, for better and worse, when the going gets tough. It adds up to a skillful kind of mosaic that pays powerful emotional dividends.
Read - 8.0 The Wall Street JournalJoe Morgenstern
The intimacy of Ms. Johnson’s performance is extraordinary. She is the least assertive of movie stars, yet the courage, despair and fury she finds in Nicole will lift you up and spin you around.
- 7.5 The PlaylistElla Kemp
The sensitivity of these performances, particularly from Affleck and Segel, offers a reckoning on sincere friendship and the limits of devotion that remains with the viewer, long after the days of waiting and the years of pain have finally come to an end.
Read - 7.5 Chicago Sun-TimesRichard Roeper
“Our Friend” occasionally goes overboard on the sentiment. But thanks in large part to Segel’s huggable-bear persona, Affleck’s typically steady work and Dakota Johnson turning in perhaps the most impressive performance of her career, the laughs and the tears feel quite real.
Read - 7.5 New York PostJohnny Oleksinski
Some will accuse “Our Friend” of being sentimental, and it is, but not in an “Oh no! The golden retriever was kidnapped!” way. It’s subtle. The wisdom of Brad Ingelsby’s script is that Dane’s assistance is unnoticeable until very late in the movie. His acts of kindness sneak up on you.
Read - 7.5 San Francisco ChronicleMick LaSalle
Our Friend is both a tribute to a friend and to those rare people that are too humble to realize their own wisdom.
- 7.5 Roger EbertSheila O'Malley
But “Our Friend” is very good where it really counts and that’s on the small details, the everyday life aspect of doing errands, cooking dinner, while your family is going through this harrowing ordeal. Cancer consumes the patient, but it also ravages the family.
Read - 7.5 Movie NationRoger Moore
That diffuse focus and meandering narrative is the only real shortcoming in this consequential and touching weeper.
Read - 7.5 The Boston GlobeTy Burr
Some things remain a mystery. If we were a little bit better as people, this decent, clear-eyed movie hints, they might not.
Read - 7.0 Screen DailyFionnuala Halligan
This is a tasteful, respectful and thoughtful film about what it means to be a true friend in the darkest of times
Read - 7.0 Vanity FairKatey Rich
It’s a small-scale human story, precious few of which make it to film these days. It’s also, if you’re in the market for that kind of thing, an extremely effective tearjerker.
Read - 6.7 The Austin ChronicleSteve Davis
Aside from Segel’s grounding performance, the pleasures of Our Friend lie in some of its observational specifics about human behavior.
Read - 6.7 The A.V. ClubA.A. Dowd
It’s sweet and involving and occasionally even moving, but also, in its selective dramatization, a lot easier. Which is to say, it approaches the story itself rather euphemistically, handling the audience with kid gloves by eliding the most unpleasant truths of the family’s experience.
Read - 6.0 CinemaníaAndrea G. Bermejo
Hard-going as it is, 'Our Friend' is a long way from the painful rawness of the article that inspired it.
Read - 5.8 The Film StageGlenn Heath Jr.
All in all, Cowperthwaite (who directed the documentary Blackfish and made her narrative debut with Megan Leavey) has a difficult time giving the film any sense of style. Montages pop up exactly where one would expect, and nasty arguments are given the classic hand-held touch.
Read - 5.0 IndiewireDavid Ehrlich
Most of the fault lies with the fragmented, nonlinear structure “The Friend” uses to approximate the flowing nature of the Esquire piece.
Read - 4.0 The GuardianBenjamin Lee
While the screenwriter, Brad Ingelsby, does root us in the minutiae of the trio’s day-to-day, it’s never in particularly interesting ways, and over an indulgent 135-minute runtime, we gradually grow tired of them, often questioning exactly why we need to know so much about their lives.
Read - 3.8 The Globe and MailBarry Hertz
The resulting film, while sporadically affecting, is ultimately a slog of gooey sentiment and needlessly long death rattles.
Read - 3.0 The Hollywood ReporterDeborah Young
Overlaying the drama with the false cheer of lively music and bouts of humor, the story feels out of touch with the very emotions it desperately tries to evoke. Neither tearjerker nor very affecting drama, it defaults to somewhere in the middle.
Read - 3.0 VarietyPeter Debruge
So much of the unpleasantness has been scrubbed from the picture, until what remains is precisely the kind of dishonest, sanitized no-help-to-anyone TV-movie version of death that inspired Teague to set the record straight in the first place.
Read - 3.0 New York TimesJeannette Catsoulis
This drippy drama presents precisely the kind of prettified portrait of death that Teague’s candid writing sought to rebut.
Questions about the reviews of Our Friend
- What score does Our Friend have?
- The critics, 6.2 on average from 21 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Our Friend?
- The highest score is Los Angeles Times’s (8.0) and the lowest New York Times’s (3.0).