Out of Darkness: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.9 from 28 outlets
- 9.1 IndiewireAlison Foreman
But as a scathing metaphor for humanity's original sin, "Out of Darkness" is a revelatory feast of cranial gore and heady philosophy — one that's not only worthy of a trek to the movie theaters mid Oscars season, but that has Cumming snagging an early lead in the race for best horror debut of 2024.
Read - 9.0 New York TimesJeannette Catsoulis
Unfolding entirely in a fictional language (which the actors deliver with fluid conviction), and enriched by lovingly rendered practical effects, this first feature from Andrew Cumming pairs its minimalist narrative with the maximum of atmosphere.
Read - 8.5 Paste MagazineMatthew Jackson
The aim is to deliver something that's both a gripping throwback and a shockingly timeless exploration of human terror. Happily for horror fans, the film mostly hits the mark, and becomes a must-see genre film along the way.
Read - 8.0 DeadlineDamon Wise
The Highlands of Scotland are the perfect backdrop for Andrew Cumming’s prehistoric genre piece Out of Darkness, a survivalist horror that also works as a thoughtful human drama as its core cast of six fight for their lives against a violent, unseen creature.
Read - 8.0 The Daily BeastNick Schager
Equal parts Quest for Fire, Prey, The Descent, and even Prometheus, it's a midnight movie that recognizes that there's no existence without sacrifice, and no birth without death.
Read - 8.0 Time OutPhil de Semlyen
It's anthropology, not violence, that provides the sting in the tail – a thought-provoking coda to an often pulse-pounding survival horror.
Read - 8.0 The ScotsmanAlistair Harkness
Filmed in Scotland and set 45,000 years ago, Out of Darkness is a robust big screen experience at a time when too many films are only too happy to satisfy the small screen expectations of the streaming services
Read - 8.0 Screen DailyNikki Baughan
While the film may not fully cash in on that premise until its ferocious final 20 minutes, Cumming (a Screen Star Of Tomorrow in 2021) has nevertheless made an intelligent and effective homegrown horror.
Read - 8.0 Dread CentralSean McGeady
'The Origin' is a proper dirt-under-the-nails debut and a fierce case for British genre filmmaking.
Read - 8.0 Sight and SoundKim Newman
Andrew Cumming's savage feature debut doesn't stint on the scares – and weaves in troubling questions about the primal history of human violence.
Read - 7.5 Roger EbertGlenn Kenny
The story told in “Out of Darkness” is ultimately sad more than terrifying, a parable about violence and the roots of human war. It’s an impressively credible and gnarly journey back in time.
Read - 7.5 Movie NationRoger Moore
The frights may be standard issue, but that novel setting, the ways characters rise to or shrink from their greatest tests, and the grim nature of human life in this most fragile of ages make "Out of Darkness" a winner, right down to the minimalist pun of its title.
Read - 7.0 VarietyDennis Harvey
On a story level, “Out of Darkness” may be less than memorable, but its simultaneously poetical and perilous atmosphere leaves a strong impression, stirring anticipation for whatever Cumming (whose résumé previously consisted of shorts and TV episodes) will do next.
Read - 7.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer
Almost a film-school lesson in how to make a movie full of tension and mystery on a shoestring budget, Out of Darkness is a minimalist thriller set in the Stone Age, 45,000 years ago.
Read - 7.0 The Arizona RepublicBill Goodykoontz
Even at less than an hour and a half, the film is, shall we say, patient in unfolding its story. Part of this is set up, lulling the audience for the shocks to come.
Read - 7.0 Loud and Clear ReviewsWilliam Stottor
Thrilling and terrifying in equal measure whilst also respectfully borrowing from standout horrors such as The Blair Witch Project and The Descent, Cumming's feature film debut is a propulsive journey back to the very inception of our existence.
Read - 6.7 The Austin ChronicleRichard Whittaker
Cumming presents a natural world red in tooth and claw, yet the inevitable lessons learned in this moss-covered and frost-blasted wilderness still have modern resonances – about fear, bigotry, superstition, survival.
Read - 6.3 Slant MagazineRoss McIndoe
Shot in the Scottish Highlands, Out of Darkness draws on the eerie atmosphere of a place that still feels ancient and steeped in mystery.
Read - 6.0 ColliderChase Hutchinson
Out of Darkness is an often jaw-dropping horror debut that arrives at a more substantive conclusion that makes everything more interesting in retrospect.
Read - 6.0 Screen RantAlexander Harrison
It's almost like Cumming has made two films, one through aesthetics and atmosphere and one through story and theme, that ultimately can't coexist.
Read - 6.0 The GuardianCath Clarke
That said, miraculously this film is never silly. The recreation of stone age life feels unexpectedly convincing
Read - 6.0 The ObserverEllen E Jones
Proof that even the most basic cinematic tools can be used to make fire.
Read - 6.0 EmpireVictoria Luxford
Atmospheric and chilling, Out Of Darkness doesn't reinvent the wheel, but adds some thoughtful twists to a well-worn genre. It's an intriguing sign of things to come from a new filmmaking voice.
Read - 6.0 The Wee ReviewKevin Wight
Its staging and thrill levels don't quite meet the standards of the impeccable atmosphere, courtesy of the imposing Scottish scenery, natural lighting, and an incredible elemental score
Read - 5.0 The PlaylistBrian Farvour
At the very least, Oakley-Green has enough presence to set up the potential for something equally captivating in better films, and while "Out of Darkness" is by no means bad, it's far from the iconic status Cumming presumably hoped to achieve.
Read - 5.0 Los Angeles TimesJoshua Rothkopf
"Out of Darkness" is effective enough — and gory — to function as a thriller of the loud-noise-springing variety. But a last-act grasp at profundity in Ruth Greenberg's screenplay feels unearned.
Read - 4.2 The Film StageEthan Vestby
Yet it's lacking in the genuine requirements for this kind of picture––any real suspense, terror, or ickiness
Read - 4.0 The Village VoiceMichael Atkinson
First-time director Andrew Cumming tries to keep it tough-minded and realistic, and in the process bleeds the movie of invention and fun — inadvertently revealing, you could conclude, why so few films are set in 45,000 BCE.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Out of Darkness
- What score does Out of Darkness have?
- The critics, 6.9 on average from 28 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Out of Darkness?
- The highest score is Indiewire’s (9.1) and the lowest The Village Voice’s (4.0).