Reviews
The Bay of Silence
Directed by Paula van der Oest · starring Claes Bang, Olga Kurylenko and Brian Cox
- 32 from the press
The Bay of Silence: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 5.3 from 32 outlets
- 8.0 Film AuthorityEddie Harrison
...a dark, adult thriller with a succession of disturbing twists that ensure the viewer is kept guessing...
Read - 8.0 The Hollywood NewsKat Hughes
Mystery, intrigue and excellent performances combine to create a truly intoxicating thriller that is devastatingly absorbing.
Read - 7.5 Behind The LensDebbie Lynn Elias
A mesmerizing and intriguing tale of secrets, lies, and love, The Bay of Silence speaks volumes
Read - 7.0 VarietyGuy Lodge
The film’s pained, ugly revelations finally carry more weight than any amateur detective work leading up to them: a #MeToo reckoning hidden within a glinting, noir-esque hall of mirrors.
Read - 7.0 Eye for FilmJennie Kermode
Kurylenko, increasingly impressive across the span of her work, is on fine form as the troubled young woman with secrets she can't speak and may not even fully understand herself.
Read - 7.0 What She SaidAnne Brodie
This atmospheric and sinister universe is ironically sun-dappled and gorgeous, as its quiet power gets under the skin.
Read - 6.7 Dennis Schwartz Movie ReviewsDennis Schwartz
This noir type of Hitchcockian thriller falls short. It needed the Master himself to direct it.
Read - 6.7 Boston HeraldJames Verniere
A Hitchcock knockoff in the tradition of "Marnie" and "Rebecca." Bang and Kurylenko lack chemistry, and the plot is more travelogue than intriguing.
Read - 6.7 Assignment XAbbie Bernstein
Director Paula van der Oest gets such a sumptuous look that we don't question the film's title.
Read - 6.3 Seattle Film BlogKathy Fennessy
If [Paula van der Oest's] film isn't quite the disaster its reputation might suggest, it doesn't add up to a whole lot, despite the filmmaker's attempts to grapple with serious issues like mental illness and sexual abuse.
Read - 6.0 The Hollywood ReporterDavid Rooney
Mostly, however, it’s the actors who keep things compelling even when the plotting gets untidy.
Read - 6.0 Shadows on the WallRich Cline
There's a Hitchcockian layer of suspense beneath even the happiest scenes in this mystery thriller.
Read - 6.0 Common Sense MediaKat Halstead
Tense psychological drama has adult themes.
Read - 6.0 The Hollywood OutsiderAaron Peterson
Claes Bang and Olga Kurylenko elevate this fascinating take on the effects of childhood trauma.
Read - 5.5 CinemalogueTodd Jorgenson
Bang garners sympathy for his character's resilience and dedication, while the film maintains consistent tension before stumbling down the stretch.
Read - 5.5 AIPTNathaniel Muir
The performances are strong, but the story never connects with the audience. There is a lot going on, but little seems to happen in this twist heavy thriller.
Read - 5.5 ScreenAnarchyMichele "Izzy" Galgana
Still, The Bay of Silence is a fun popcorn thriller at times, even if the film is uneven. Bang is quite interesting to watch, whether he's got great source material to work from or not.
Read - 5.0 Jim SchembriJim Schembri
As far as mystery-thrillers go it contains the requisite number of twists and turns after drawing you in with a seductive opening reel. Director Paula van der Oest does a deft job of shifting atmospheric gear...A serviceable thriller.
Read - 5.0 Orca SoundCarey-Ann Pawsey
Secondary story upon secondary story. Instead of them adding to the intrigue they just make things a jumble.
Read - 5.0 DeadlinePete Hammond
The actors including Claes Bang and Brian Cox are saving graces in a wannabe Hitchcockian thriller that is unfortunately more muddled than mystery.
Read - 5.0 ShockyaHarvey S. Karten
You may need to read the book to figure out what's going on here.
Read - 4.0 New York TimesBen Kenigsberg
There is less to The Bay of Silence than meets the eye.
Read - 4.0 The GuardianCath Clarke
You search for emotion in the faces of the actors: howling grief, rage, confusion, mild irritation with the preposterous plot. Nothing. Not even a twitch.
Read - 4.0 Denerstein UnleashedRobert Denerstein
...despite a game cast, the movie induces more head-scratching than suspense or mystery.
Read - 4.0 IONCINEMA.comNicholas Bell
The Bay of Silence isn't unenjoyable, but its major crime is having all the trappings of a juicy meal only to disappoint with an utter lack of flourish or flavor.
Read - 4.0 Easy ReaderNeely Swanson
It's almost a thriller, it's almost a mystery, it's almost a love story; but in the end, it's a muddle.
Read - 4.0 Flickering MythRobert Kojder
There's no time like the present to tell stories about sexual assault survivors, but they should probably be less trashy and tasteless than The Bay of Silence
Read - 3.8 Mark Reviews MoviesMark Dujsik
Much of this story is ultimately a hunt for exposition.
Read - 3.5 Flickering MythTori Brazier
The Bay of Silence strives to be an exciting film-noir-come-psycho-melodrama, but it just lacks the subtlety and refinement.
Read - 3.5 The Weekend WarriorEdward Douglas
A highly uneven and bland thriller that tries to offer a twist a minute with very of them ever really connecting.
Read - 2.5 Roger EbertOdie Henderson
I suppose director Paula van der Oest was trying to go for some kind of European Gothic feel, but something this unsavory needs to move a lot faster than this. This contraption is slower than molasses in winter.
Read - 2.0 Ready Steady CutM.N. Miller
The Bay of Silence has a plot and reveal so weak it would not qualify for a below-average episode of Law & Order.
Read
Questions about the reviews of The Bay of Silence
- What score does The Bay of Silence have?
- The critics, 5.3 on average from 32 reviews.
- What do the critics say about The Bay of Silence?
- The highest score is Film Authority’s (8.0) and the lowest Ready Steady Cut’s (2.0).