7.8The Austin ChronicleMatthew MonagleWith a small cast and a handful of locations – the only other character of note is Rachel (Seimetz), Thomas’ unsuspecting wife – The Secrets We Keep blends the best of B-movie thrillers and black box theatre.Read
7.0Los Angeles TimesKevin CrustThe genre elements are nicely balanced by the adult drama embodied in the lead quartet’s performances, especially Rapace’s turn that is part femme fatale, part damaged soul.Read
6.7Original-CinKim HughesApproached with a casual regard for logic, period thriller The Secrets We Keep is entertaining enough to recommend though it never feels quite as original or shocking as the filmmakers — working with a plainly Hitchcockian roadmap — likely hoped for.Read
6.3Slant MagazineDerek SmithThe film is ultimately too tidy to embrace anything truly startling or unexpected, either stylistically or narratively.Read
6.0The Hollywood ReporterSheri LindenA dramatic thriller tackling serious themes — the aftermath of war, the cost of retribution and the possibility of redemption — the movie can’t always get out of its own way, as reliably effective as Rapace is.Read
6.0VarietyDennis HarveyThis “Death and the Maiden”-like suspense drama is neither fully convincing nor particularly original, its narrative running a course that feels somewhat predictable from the outset. But it’s still strong enough to be effectiveRead
6.0The TelegraphRobbie CollinWhat sense there is of big ideas being thoughtfully chewed over stems largely from Rapace’s steely, wounded central performance, which often feels like a decade-later echo of her work in the Girl with the Dragon Tattoo films.Read
5.0The Film StageChristian GallichioThe Secrets We Keep is a film in search of a more coherent message.Read
5.0The Globe and MailBarry Hertza solid, well-acted, and slightly predictable drama of morals whose novelty evaporates once you realize that the general beats of the story itself have been presented before, to far more haunting effect.Read
4.2Entertainment WeeklyMary SollosiFor the most part, though, these secrets aren't worth passing along.Read
4.2IndiewireDavid EhrlichA listless, half-baked, vaguely Hitchcockian thriller about a Romani Holocaust survivorRead
4.0The WrapAlonso DuraldeWhat grates about director Yuval Adler and his co-writer Ryan Covington pilfering so obviously from Dorfman’s work is that they haven’t done anything particularly interesting with it.Read
3.0New York TimesBen KenigsbergAn exploitation film that proceeds as if it were a solemn memorial, The Secrets We Keep doesn’t do right by the Holocaust history it invokes — or much else.Read
2.5Roger EbertGlenn KennyWhile I rather doubt that co-writer/director Yuval Adler pitched his new picture as “’Death and the Maiden’ meets ‘Leave it to Beaver,’” that sure is what he ended up with, conceptually at least.Read