With Hasan in Gaza: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 8.0 from 15 outlets
- 10 Roger EbertMarya E. Gates
While this undercurrent of death courses through the whole film, by contrasting it with scenes like the one described above, Aljafari crafts a film about resilience and about love. A film that centers on community and family, finding strength in this communion despite all the horrors that must be endured.
Read - 9.1 The Film StageRory O'Connor
To call 'With Hasan in Gaza' a personal work would be an understatement, but its message is as clear as it is universal.
Read - 9.0 Sight and SoundArron Kennon
With this crux, to film, or not to film, 'With Hasan in Gaza' brilliantly centres the need to bear witness as no less than a matter of life and death, preservation and loss, liberation and occupation.
Read - 9.0 POV MagazinePat Mullen
The power of durational cinema comes full force in 'With Hasan in Gaza'.
Read - 8.0 NYC Movie GuruAvi Offer
'With Hasan in Gaza' is an immersive, timely, haunting and heartbreaking documentary.
Read - 8.0 Screen DailyAmber Wilkinson
The result is a raw but poignant snapshot of Gaza during the Second Intifada.
Read - 8.0 In Review OnlineRobert Stinner
A sober presentation of a nearly forgotten archive that briefly vivifies what has been irretrievably lost, 'With Hasan in Gaza' is a vital and mournful work of preservation.
Read - 8.0 CinencuentroMarcelo Paredes
That choice can make it a more demanding watch, even a challenging one for some viewers, but it also gives the film an unusual authenticity.
Read - 8.0 Diario PanoramaSilvina Pachelo
It moves you by the way it exists. Every piece of rubble, every Israeli checkpoint, every collapse is a return to the past: a visual elegy.
Read - 7.8 Spectrum CultureErik Reeds
As with many of the great Palestinian films of the last few years, 'With Hasan in Gaza' is able to capture the frustration and hopelessness that many have felt in the region for decades, if not their entire lives.
Read - 7.5 Slant MagazineEli Friedberg
The result is both a document of a precise historical moment and testament to the continuity of Palestinian memory and struggle.
Read - 7.0 Loud and Clear ReviewsClotilde Chinnici
The largely unedited cut is not easy to watch and can admittedly become repetitive, but it is worth it for the unique story it portrays.
Read - 7.0 CinemagaviaEduardo Gil Rodríguez
Kamal Aljafari doesn't mention the present explicitly, but he draws a direct line between 2001 and today. The violence doesn't appear as an exception but as a continuity.
Read - 7.0 Otros CinesDiego Batlle
The analysis could include some reservation or objection, but that footage now serves as a historical record, a reclaiming of memory and, in its own way, a tribute to many of those people.
Read - 6.0 New York TimesBen Kenigsberg
While there is value in any documentary evidence of this time and place, Aljafari's allusive approach seems ill-matched with the urgency of his subject matter.
Read
Questions about the reviews of With Hasan in Gaza
- What score does With Hasan in Gaza have?
- The critics, 8.0 on average from 15 reviews.
- What do the critics say about With Hasan in Gaza?
- The highest score is Roger Ebert’s (10) and the lowest New York Times’s (6.0).