Reviews
Being Heumann
Directed by Sian Heder · starring Mark Ruffalo, Dylan O'Brien and Rob Delaney
- 43 from the press
Being Heumann: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.7 from 43 outlets
- 9.1 The Film MavenKristen Lopez
Being Heumann is an essential piece of disabled cinema, laying out a stark foundation for the fight for disability rights.
Read - 8.3 IndiewireKate Erbland
A film like “Being Heumann” is destined to be called rousing — a call to action that’s every bit as entertaining as it is inspiring. It’s a film about tough choices and even tougher circumstances, but it’s also about the tangible good that can come from people working together.
Read - 8.0 VarietyOwen Gleiberman
“Being Heumann” isn’t as transporting a movie as “CODA” was, yet it’s a stirring drama cut from the same cloth of cathartic empathy. And it’s also structurally bold.
Read - 8.0 Next Best PictureNadia Dalimonte
Heder brings humor and heart to “Being Heumann,” crafting a very compassionate portrayal of people with disabilities and their daily resilience. It’s Heder’s finest work yet, and needless to say, an excellent follow-up to “CODA.”
Read - 8.0 ColliderJoe Schmidt
The title of the film is an apt play on words that gets to the heart of why Heder's latest film works so well. It beautifully captures an era and a group of people who risked everything to change the world.
Read - 8.0 The WrapSteve Pond
You pretty much know it’s going to get triumphant, at least to some degree, and Heder knows how to work triumph on screen. There’s no question that she’s pulled off another crowd-pleasing film, but the key to “Being Heumann” is that its importance goes beyond those audience smiles.
Read - 8.0 DeadlineGlenn Garner
Not only does the film capture these stories with enormous compassion, but it also humanizes people with disabilities in ways that many projects fail to do while depicting the experience as either tragedy or inspiration porn.
Read - 8.0 HeyUGuysLinda Marric
At its centre is a woman who is both likeable and a complete pain in the ass. That combination is what makes her feel like a real person rather than a monument, and it is why the film works so well.
Read - 7.5 The PlaylistAnkit Jhunjhunwala
For all its conventionality and occasionally overinsistent messaging, Heder’s film understands something essential about its subjects: disabled people need neither pity nor sainthood to deserve autonomy, dignity, pleasure, and full participation in society.
Read - 7.5 Roger EbertZachary Lee
Sian Heder’s “Being Heumann” is a stellar example of a film that wholeheartedly believes in the power of its story and message, so much so that it knows that all it needs to do is ensure the craft around it amplifies rather than distracts.
Read - 7.5 The Film StageAlistair Ryder
It still manages to be rousing despite these flaws, the familiarity of its comfortable tone making it easier to commend the ways it breaks from the Miramax formula.
Read - 7.5 The Seattle TimesMoira Macdonald
“Being Heumann” is a moving and fascinating story of an American hero, one whose name you may not know.
Read - 7.5 Mark Reviews MoviesMark Dujsik
Heder’s film, then, is genuinely inspiring—not in some generic or patronizing way but in that way that matters and that might be a help.
Read - 7.5 Reeling ReviewsLaura Clifford
Even those who may remember the protests which resulted in a sea change may take these things for granted now and those who do not will likely be shocked to see how people with disabilities were treated in this country as recently as the 1970's.
Read - 7.5 The Travers TakePeter Travers
Its focus is on the 1970s protests that helped win Judith Heumann, played with appropriately fabulous flair by Ruth Madeley, the title of “mother of the disability rights movement.”
Read - 7.0 The Hollywood ReporterDavid Rooney
But the characters and the disabled actors playing them are so engaging in their unbroken perseverance and their levity even in the face of harsh setbacks — a late-night raid by cops is especially hair-raising — that it’s impossible not to keep rooting for them.
Read - 7.0 Screen RantJosh Bate
Heder's movie gives viewers a better understanding of the title character and her achievements (and the disability rights movement of the 1970s more broadly), while still ensuring that the story is engaging enough that the educational aspect never completely takes over.
Read - 7.0 Otros CinesDiego Batlle
Perhaps a little long (the 127 minutes feel somewhat excessive), but made with plenty of black humour, boldness, irreverence, sensitivity, tenderness and a powerful political outlook (...), Being Heumann finds, not only in Ruth Madeley's performance but also in the rest of a cast made up mostly of performers with different degrees of disability, a naturalness, a credibility and an empathy that are welcome and worth celebrating.
Read - 7.0 Algo más que cineDionar Hidalgo
The film knows which moments to pick out and how to steer the viewer towards an emotional conclusion, but it rarely lets itself explore the complexities of its subject or the contradictions of a political fight in any depth.
Read - 7.0 CinemalogueTodd Jorgenson
Madeley’s galvanizing portrayal steers an earnest yet rousing film that balances humor and humanity while largely avoiding heavy-handed messaging.
Read - 7.0 Culture MixCarla Hay
“Being Heumann” succeeds in being an inspirational drama about disability rights activist Judith “Judy” Heumann leading a landmark sit-in protest for accessibility reforms.
Read - 7.0 Richard CrouseRichard Crouse
“Being Heumann” could have used a bit more grit and a little less made-for-television style, but the story is undeniably affecting.
Read - 7.0 CinefiedJosh Davis
Seeing this many disabled performers get to be funny, angry, awkward, and desired matters. So does the care with which they’re filmed.
Read - 6.7 Blu-ray.comBrian Orndorf
It’s the best part of “Being Heumann,” which is as well-intentioned as a movie can get, but doesn’t return to the same level of cinematic language, preferring to use speeches and showy performances instead.
Read - 6.5 ScreenAnarchyOlga Artemyeva
For all the fun shenanigans in it, Being Heumann is mostly a bittersweet movie that serves as a reminder of a deeply ironic fact: the ways of the world are so often changed by the people who lived through being restricted in one way or another.
Read - 6.3 Slant MagazineKenji Fujishima
Being Heumann may be a new landmark in disability representation, but, as with CODA, you’ll have to wade through slick sentimentality and simplistic hagiography to find the enlightening bits.
Read - 6.0 The GuardianRichard Lawson
If only Being Heumann held its cool, rebellious pose for a bit longer, the spirit of the movement might have been truly conjured up. Instead, things deflate into a competent recitation of facts, into a sturdy but plain message delivery system.
Read - 6.0 Screen DailyTim Grierson
As predictable as Being Heumann can be as an underdog narrative, Heder’s clear affection for her characters shines through. And it should not be discounted how rare it is to see a major motion picture starring disabled, Deaf and Blind performers who get to play characters with significant screen time and dimensionality.
Read - 6.0 MicropsiaDiego Lerer
Sincere, humane and well-meaning, if a little clumsy dramatically and rather linear, it is in more ways than one comparable to Heder's previous film, which centred on a deaf family with a daughter who wanted to be a singer.
Read - 6.0 Chicago ReaderNoah Berlatsky
Being Heumann is not necessarily a great movie. It does provide a vital history of disability activism, though, and a blueprint for ongoing change, onscreen and off.
Read - 6.0 Flickering MythRobert Kojder
Credit to Sian Heder and especially the remarkable disabled ensemble for what they have accomplished here, but Being Heumann, while full of observations on disabled life, unfortunately gets too busy being hokey and paint-by-numbers in its storytelling.
Read - 6.0 The GuardianPeter Bradshaw
It’s a high-energy ensemble film about the messy business of challenging the status quo.
Read - 6.0 Time OutElizabeth Weitzman
What’s too often missing, unfortunately, is the three-dimensional humanity that would elevate an undeniably admirable project into an artistically creative one.
Read - 6.0 Ty Burr's Watch ListTy Burr
Another inspirational true-life drama.
Read - 5.8 AwardsWatchTrace Sauveur
Not every film needs to completely break the mold, but the two-plus-hour runtime of Being Heumann begins to sag as you realize Heder has no intention of moving beyond the well-meaning earnestness that has come to define her on-screen portrayal of the disabled.
Read - 5.8 The A.V. ClubAnna McKibbin
Being Heumann doesn’t reach the heights of its thrilling real-world event, but there’s still plenty to enjoy in its creative rendering of how different disabilities overlap, constrict, and expand any group’s possibilities.
Read - 5.5 The Daily BeastNick Schager
Ironically, for a story about unique outsiders fighting to be seen, heard, and accepted as they are, it follows every groan-worthy rule in the rah-rah uplift playbook.
Read - 5.5 Shade StudiosAlfred Castaneda
Despite the bold personalities, Being Heumann still feels rather clinical and predictable.
Read - 5.0 VultureAlison Willmore
What accessibility means to Heder, as a filmmaker who wants to reach the broadest possible audience, and to Heumann and her cohort, who are battling for curb cuts and other changes to allow them to participate in public life, are two very different and sometimes contradictory things.
Read - 5.0 New York PostJohnny Oleksinski
What gets in the director’s way is her tendency to fall into the beat-by-beat conventions of historical storytelling. “Heumann” feels like too many other us-against-the-man movies to the point of being soothing rather than galvanizing.
Read - 5.0 Los Angeles TimesRobert Abele
“Being Heumann” is never dull, because this incident and its impact were never dull, nor was the principled, unwavering Heumann herself.
Read - 4.2 Movies Thru the SpectrumAl Alexander
She looks the part, but she falls short of capturing Heumann’s spirit and vivacious personality.
Read - 4.0 The RevealScott Tobias
There are small brushfires here and there about strategy, mostly aimed at the limits of Heumann’s combative approach, but Heder draws the battle lines too plainly, with virtue on one side and bureaucratic cowardice on the other.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Being Heumann
- What score does Being Heumann have?
- The critics, 6.7 on average from 43 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Being Heumann?
- The highest score is The Film Maven’s (9.1) and the lowest The Reveal’s (4.0).