Reviews
Shadow in the Cloud
starring Chloë Grace Moretz, Nick Robinson and Taylor John Smith
- 22 from the press
Shadow in the Cloud: reviews
Reviews
What the critics say average 6.8 from 22 outlets
- 9.0 VarietyPeter Debruge
Hardly a minute of the movie registers as “realistic,” but that hardly matters, since Liang so fully commits to its over-the-top sensibility that you’ll be clutching the armrest and grinning with glee for most of the ride.
Read - 8.0 The Hollywood ReporterJohn DeFore
This ride is much more fun when you know nothing about it going in.
Read - 8.0 El PeriódicoNando Salvà
'Shadow in the Cloud' is nowhere near a perfect film. At a certain point it starts paying too explicit attention to the creature, and the narrative devices it uses to deliver its feminist message are problematic (explaining why would mean spoilers); even so, it deserves admiration for its impossible action sequences, its willingness to do whatever it takes not to bore, and the pride with which it wears its trash-cinema status.
Read - 8.0 EspinofJorge Loser
Rarely does a simple idea lead to a result as polished, vibrant and well executed as in ‘Shadow in the Cloud’.
Read - 7.8 The WrapAlonso Duralde
“Shadow in the Cloud” has that boisterous B-movie energy, and it’s a reminder that narrative shamelessness is permissible, even welcome, in the hands of an assured storyteller.
Read - 7.5 The A.V. ClubKatie Rife
But if you can save the questions for after the movie’s over and concentrate on the pulpy derring-do, it doesn’t ruin the fun.
Read - 7.5 IndiewireKate Erbland
Part creature feature, part war-is-hell nightmare, and entirely dedicated to cutting down the misogynist jerks who populate it, there’s enough giddy fun to power “Shadow in the Cloud” through just about anything.
Read - 7.5 Chicago Sun-TimesRichard Roeper
The deeper “Shadow in the Cloud” dives into sci-fi fantasy territory, the more we’re asked to just go with it and enjoy the spectacularly choreographed action sequences — but thanks in large part to Moretz’s ferociously effective work, we’re all too happy to take that zany ride.
Read - 7.5 Original-CinJim Slotek
Effectively the Ripley of this flight, Moretz makes a good case – again - for her ability to work an action film. Shadow in the Cloud is a fun ride through enemy territory, both human and demonic, and Moretz wields her weaponry with aplomb.
- 7.0 Screen DailyWendy Ide
A sufficiently motivated woman is a fearsome and unstoppable force: the central premise for this gleefully pulpy WWII horror puts a dash of feminist fury into a schlocky B movie set-up.
Read - 7.0 The Arizona RepublicBill Goodykoontz
It's never less than edge-of-your-seat fun.
Read - 7.0 Los Angeles TimesNoel Murray
If not for Moretz’s expressive face, the film might stall out before it really gets rolling. It does get rolling though … and at maximum speed.
Read - 7.0 New York TimesDevika Girish
The twists come rapidly in the movie’s first half; in the second, the narrative dissolves into a zigzag of flying bodies and explosions that bend the laws of space-time. But the implausibility of it all is a perk: There’s never a moment in this rollicking film when you can tell what’s coming next.
Read - 7.0 Rolling Stone en EspañolAndré Didyme-Dôme
After the first act, Liang keeps us hooked and gives us no time to breathe, building to a finale that is over the top, ridiculous, but hugely entertaining for those who know exactly what ride they signed up for.
Read - 6.3 Slant MagazineSteven Scaife
Roseanne Liang leverages the absolute implausibility of the film’s later scenes into something brisk and exciting right to the very end.
Read - 6.3 Movie NationRoger Moore
It’s a performance of compact, comical fury packed into a movie that cost what they wasted on the “Wonder Woman 1984” avocado toast catering, a little B-movie that could, headed by a pint-sized badass with “Grace” as her middle name.
Read - 6.3 Roger EbertNick Allen
Roseanne Liang’s “Shadow in the Cloud” is the type of genre movie that makes many of its bizarre choices just for the sake of seeing if it can all work. But whether you find the film to be ambitious, or just some stunt screenwriting, it’s intriguing to watch an audacious filmmaker try to keep midnight-ready movies unpredictable, even if that means a sincere but silly mash-up of WWII dogfights, gremlin chaos, and feminism in action such as this.
Read - 6.0 Film ThreatAlex Saveliev
In more confident hands, Shadow in the Cloud could have been a demented allegory about female empowerment; instead, it’s just demented, albeit damn entertaining. Here’s hoping Landis gets his head out of the clouds and writes something that casts lingering shadows next time.
Read - 6.0 Rolling StoneDavid Fear
While this mix of thrills, chills and eyeroll-inducing WTFs is an inauspicious way to start a moviegoing year, it’s the type of viewing lark that works best through the haze of a long day’s journey into last night’s hangover. It isn’t bad. It should be better.
Read - 5.8 The Film StageJared Mobarak
Those who enjoy a good hoot and holler with a midnight crowd will surely revel in it while those who don’t will roll their eyes and wonder what’s happening since the reveal of Maude’s mission does become way too heavy-handed for its melodrama to rise above the hollow action trappings.
Read - 5.0 SlashfilmChris Evangelista
Some may get a kick out of how over-the-top and pulpy Shadow in the Cloud is, but what's on display here is so abrasive and so bombastic that it begins to sap the life out of you, ultimately leaving a bad taste in your mouth when all is said and done.
Read - 1.6 The PlaylistJason Bailey
This is an excruciatingly stupid movie, and the nicest thing I can say about it is that, at 83 minutes, at least it’s over quickly.
Read
Questions about the reviews of Shadow in the Cloud
- What score does Shadow in the Cloud have?
- The critics, 6.8 on average from 22 reviews.
- What do the critics say about Shadow in the Cloud?
- The highest score is Variety’s (9.0) and the lowest The Playlist’s (1.6).